III. Squad Evolution for 2025-26: Strengths, Gaps, and New Faces
Dundee United faces a considerable challenge in the 2025-26 season due to significant squad turnover. Several key players who contributed to their successful 2024-25 campaign have departed. Most notably, captain Ross Docherty has left the club, creating a void in both leadership and midfield presence. Goalkeeper Jack Walton, whose 112 saves topped the Premiership charts and were crucial to the team's defensive efforts, has returned to Luton Town following the expiration of his loan. Loan stars Luca Stephenson and Emmanuel Adegboyega, who each contributed 3 goals and valuable minutes, have also gone back to their parent clubs. Other experienced players departing include Declan Gallagher, Louis Moult, David Babunski, Allan Campbell, Lewis Fiorini, Ruari Paton, and Tony Watt. While not explicitly confirmed in the 2025-26 squad lists, Sam Dalby, the team's top scorer with 15 goals in 2024-25, is conspicuously absent from the listed players for the upcoming season, strongly suggesting his departure.
In response to these departures, the club has been active in the transfer market, bringing in new talent. Bert Esselink, a defender with European experience from Cyprus and Poland, has been confirmed as the fifth summer arrival. Manager Jim Goodwin has praised Esselink for his defensive capabilities and ability to play on the front foot, highlighting his mobility, bravery, and intelligence in progressive passing. The other four confirmed summer signings are Yevgeniy Kucherenko (goalkeeper), Iurie Iovu (defender), Panutche Camara (midfielder), and Zachary Sapsford (forward). These acquisitions are strategically aimed at bolstering key positions, including directly addressing the need for a new starting goalkeeper and adding depth across defense, midfield, and attack.
The simultaneous loss of the team's captain, top goalscorer, and starting goalkeeper presents a multifaceted challenge for Dundee United. The departure of Ross Docherty creates a leadership vacuum within the squad, which can impact team cohesion and on-field decision-making. The absence of Sam Dalby, the primary source of goals, directly affects the team's offensive output, which was already modest at 45 goals in 38 league games last season. Furthermore, losing Jack Walton, a goalkeeper who demonstrated exceptional shot-stopping ability, immediately places significant pressure on the new goalkeeper, Yevgeniy Kucherenko, and the overall defensive unit. Replacing these three critical pillars of the team's structure and performance simultaneously is a monumental task. While the new signings (Esselink, Kucherenko, Iovu, Camara, Sapsford) are intended to fill these roles, there is no guarantee they will immediately perform at the same level or integrate seamlessly into Jim Goodwin's system. This high turnover in crucial positions inherently increases the risk of a slower start to the season and potential inconsistencies in performance, which could directly influence their final league standing.