Rotherham’s Best and Worst loan player

[ScudTheMiller]

Just watched the Europa League game between Rangers and Borussia Dortmund and the performance from James Tavanier was exceptional. His performances in a millers shirt were mostly a joy to watch. The game against Preston in the 2nd play off semi final at NYS was a pleasure to behold..he was unplayable at times. Another gem was Noah Dicko who’s memorable game against Wolves prompted them to manufacture a move for the in form striker. Worst loan singing.. there are too many to choose from so I’ll open that one up to floor.

[Lolmorgan]

That’s easy worst, HIRST. We have had some very good goalkeepers on loan.Who ever sanctioned Hirsts loan didn’t look at his stats, very poor from us.

[millertop]

Scott Allan pissed me off to the max for his laziness
Reg is good
We’ve had some good keepers then there was Roos 😂

[Masbroughstreet]

Agree about Tavernier. I'd also add Keiffer Moore to the list for potentially our best loan signing. Carl Robinson under Ronnie was a great one as well.

As for worst, we've had plenty. How many players did Evans sign on loan who hardly played and then were never seen again?

[jakethemiller]

Jodie Morris was a good un.

[harpo88]

Mark Randall for me, lotsa promise from Arsenal when we were I think in League Two but massively disappointing - shows how well Dan Barlaser has done well as Randall was a similar type of player on paper but Dan’s got such a great all round game for his position with us now.

[Brin]

Martinez brilliant keeper. Has to be Hirst by a country mile one I think Warne wish he hadn’t signed.

[Townerslovechild]

What was the German lad called that Ronnie got from Forest ?
He was good.

[millertop]

What was the German lad called that Ronnie got from Forest ?
He was good.

Eugen Bopp bopp Bopp? He wasn’t a loan was he?

[Scum-Triumphant]

Who was the lad from Liverpool that was touted as the next Michael Owen.

He scuffed a shot from the half way like and I never saw him again.

Morgan maybe?