Dundee

[deek5trans]

Was there any need to send him off though? Were Dundee denied a clear goal scoring opportunity? Will be interesting to see the footage. I wouldn't be surprised if there was no contact although Jim did appear to needlessly dive in - but it all came down to giving the ball away in midfield.


No idea how Dundee are top of the division. They were no better than us with 10 men. A very average side.

[GB72]

I do wonder sometimes. Jim was last man so had too go for the ball. From my angle I couldn't see very much but the ball was taken away from the striker, which means he wouldn't have scored anyway as a defender tracking back had the ball. Very harsh red card. Dowie was caught in-mans land. Think dowie has had 2 shocking weeks very poor and well off the pace. Kerr was good 1st but knackered 2nd. And Lyle should have burried it. But very poor Dundee team will be a long season for there fans. With hartleys defend tactics

"Will be a long season for Dundee fans"

Yeah its a total nightmare being four clear of 2nd six clear of third and whatever we are clear of you guys, absolute nightmare...

[topfitter]

Thanks to Lochar Thistle FC and Heston Rovers FC for providing the half-time entertainment at yesterdays game, pics below,

[sneddee]

defensive dundee?? w.t.f.? look at the formation m8! defo pen, keeper rightly sent off, you couldnt handle boyle. lyle's chance was a great save! we were comfortable through the game and should have had another 2 goals. you's lot are worse than average!!! look at the table in may!!!

[arrol1919]

I do wonder sometimes. Jim was last man so had too go for the ball. From my angle I couldn't see very much but the ball was taken away from the striker, which means he wouldn't have scored anyway as a defender tracking back had the ball. Very harsh red card. Dowie was caught in-mans land. Think dowie has had 2 shocking weeks very poor and well off the pace. Kerr was good 1st but knackered 2nd. And Lyle should have burried it. But very poor Dundee team will be a long season for there fans. With hartleys defend tactics

What game were you watching ? Dowie had and outstanding game yesterday . Him & Durns were solid at the back

[arrol1919]

defensive dundee?? w.t.f.? look at the formation m8! defo pen, keeper rightly sent off, you couldnt handle boyle. lyle's chance was a great save! we were comfortable through the game and should have had another 2 goals. you's lot are worse than average!!! look at the table in may!!!

In all fairness it was an average game played by two average sides yesterday .

The appointment of Hartley will win you's the league , he knows how to grind out results . As you've seen against 9 man Hamilton & 10 man Queens .

[sneddee]

i know what u'r saying m8, but in all fairness if we had taken our chances in both games we would have been out of sight and teams intend to sit in so i wouldnt say hartley grinds out results imo.

[GiroGeorge]

i know what u'r saying m8, but in all fairness if we had taken our chances in both games we would have been out of sight and teams intend to sit in so i wouldnt say hartley grinds out results imo.

yous didnt take your chances either did we yous got a 1 nil win from a penalty against 10 men, good luck for the future

[sneddee]

yes a defo pen imo, it dosnt matter how u win, 3 points all that matters m8 and we could have had a few more goals that our attacking football deserved!!! good luck if u reach the play-offs!

[arrol1919]

yes a defo pen imo, it dosnt matter how u win, 3 points all that matters m8 and we could have had a few more goals that our attacking football deserved!!! good luck if u reach the play-offs!

It was a penalty & it cost us dearly .

Time to move on . Another big game for us next Saturday away to Falkirk .

This league is still the best in Scotland & there's plenty to play for , for everyone