I am not sure what your point is Kenco.
Andy Butler has been an excellent and reliable servant both to S****horpe United and Walsall and won player of the season awards on more than one occasion at both clubs. He made an excellent start at Huddersfield but did not fit in with the plans of Lee Clark but was still good enough to be sought by Blackpool as a squad player in their Premiership campaign. Walsall were desperate to keep him and S****horpe were anxious to re-sign him in the Summer. He has the physical presence and aggression needed to defend and can score goals from set pieces. Can you honestly say that he is likely to be less useful than McCombe or the physically lightweight Mc Cullough at the heart of our disastrous back four ? How poor would you have to be to beat those two.
Just be glad that we are at least , at long last, showing signs of trying to rectify the situation we are in defensively. With full backs like Wabara and Evina any central defender is likely to be worried