jim or zander

[arrol1919]

It'll be a right slap in the face for Jim if he's dropped this weekend .

[Cresswell]

Jim Atkinson is the man in possession: he is playing well: he should stay in possession until he gives reason to do otherwise.

[mainstandman59]

Jim Atkinson is the man in possession: he is playing well: he should stay in possession until he gives reason to do otherwise.

This would be mine, and the most logical view of the goalkeeping situation.

[MCMXIX]

Jim Atkinson is the man in possession: he is playing well: he should stay in possession until he gives reason to do otherwise.

Absolutely correct . Jim must start this weekend

[TOSHSON]

Has to be Jim ,with Zander unable to play against his parent club St Johnstone ,give jim the game time before the cup game !!

[Spikefaethesouth]

I agree with the previous posts that Jim deserves him chance. There could however be an issue with St Johnstone and Zander's loan agreement. As far as they are concerned he is here to play and not to sit on the bench if fit!

[Edqos1]

Jim. If it came down to fan votes, he'd be in...

[topfitter]

No sane man or woman supporter would begrudge Jim Atkinson holding on to the No1 Jersey.

Question ; is Jim the longest serving player on Queens books just now?

[Francis_begbie_HFC]

jim is our best keeper,commands his box ,and good reflexes ,zander can be a bomb scare at times ,jim has got what it takes to go on to good things in the future .

[arrol1919]

Jim quite rightly started today but I think he might lose his place for giving away that penalty . Didn't think he should of came out for it but I may be proved wrong by another's with a better view of the incident .
Nothing he could of done about their second , it was a tremendous strike


Hibs to good for us in the end