For some reason I quite like Gabby and I really hope he has a good season in any role SB thinks fit for him. At the end of the day he plays for Villa. But you have to admit Bongo his goal return for a striker over the years has been pretty abysmal. My hopes aren't high. Hogan on the other hand scored quite a lot of goals last season albeit not for us. He has huge potential which is why he was in my team.
Btw, you and Freer have now squabbled for 12 pages on one thread. I think that's a new record!
Hogan merits a starting place because he got 21 goals in 35 games. Gabby doesn't warrant a start because he got 25 goals in 5 years.
Not sure if Gabby will fit into the starting 11 of one team but last night he did look good, got to give it to him, smart header and looks in better shape than the new Lardy in Ross Mac. Boy oh Boy he has been tucking away the battered mars bars!!
ps Johnstone in Tomorrow, leaked photo of him in villa top tonight! Now for GB?
So Gabby is better than Hogan because he didn't score in a pre season friendly game yesterday ? Never mind that he scored about 15 times as many goals as Gabby last season.
Bongo, your logic or lack thereof is mind blowing.
How many did he score for us though.
Guys, Its a new season and the slate is clean!
#Ross Mac...last chance but is a very clever player, if he gets his head together he will become a very good squad player
#Gabby....the Enigma, has failed to show for his beloved club apart from 10 mins against the sha for the last 4 years but a good start pre season, looks fit but boy oh boy he has such a lot to prove, he is in his last year of his contract and will be looking for an extension. He will not cut it at any other club so has to prove himself this season, may be the surprize package, if he is we will all be saying sorry to our Bongo!
#Hogan....Well like so many of us, wanted him in as his youtube clips looked fantastic, built like a brick 5hit house, big things are expected of him, needs an injury free season and SB to play a system that suits him.
before we know it, we will be 6 games in and hopefully these 3 will be banging the goals in while we have the Koj chomping at the bit. Could be good, we all could be right and be winners.
I agree with all that Dave. I'm not knocking Hogan and I hope he comes good. All I'm saying is you need to earn the right to ware the shirt. Hogan and McCormack has done nothing so far to justify the price tag or where the shirt despite both being good for other clubs.
If Gabby gets fat again and becomes lazy I would want him in the bench as well.
However bruse gave him a last chance and with some good man management he's took the bull by the horns. Let's just get behind the lad is all I ask. He's shown in several games last season he can cause mayhem at this level.