From the moment former Queens captain retired from playing and continued at Palmerston in his commercial capacity, this appeared good enough, along with coaching the kids around the region at the schools. When he was given the Football Development Manager's role besides being an assistant to Skelton and being in temporary charge, this was a disaster, from a 4-0 hammering at Easter Road vs Hibernian and losing to Albion Rovers 2-1 in the last seconds at Coatbridge and missing out on the Celtic Scottish Cup match, the writing was on the wall. I still don't know what he actually achieved when overseeing all age groups in his FDM role. His only highlight was getting Dobbie back to Dumfries.