Reply With QuoteYeah that Lewis definitely doesn't deserve a chance to make up for Thursday.
Hall Of Fame
After a poor show from our players and management on Thursday let's hope they get their act together and we get to see a bit of positivity from our club.
My starting eleven
Rogers
Logan
O'Connor
Arnason
Shinnie
Tansey
Christie
Wright
Stewart
May
Rooney
Hall Of Fame
Yeah that Lewis definitely doesn't deserve a chance to make up for Thursday.
Hall Of Fame
Lewis should start. With that team, you either have the dreaded back 3, or Shinnie at LB and only Tansey with any strength in midfield. I'm okay with Shinnie at LB, but think we need Ball protecting the back 4 (hopefully better than Thursday). So for me from your team, Lewis in for Rodgers and Ball in for Rooney.Originally Posted by RED_JOHN
And a far more spirited team than last week.
Hall Of Fame
A 4-4-2 Shinnie at left back to give us a bit more speed on and off the ball. Tansey and Christie in the centre of midfield as one is used more as the defensive shield and the other to create attacks through the middle.
Rogers a definite to start as Lewis should be let known that was unacceptable...imagine Rogers had played on Thursday and performed like that! No way would he be have been in the starting eleven this weekend.
The balance of that team is more or less equal...we are equipped to defend sufficiently and certainly better equipped to attack.
Hall Of Fame
You would drop a keeper who has made 1 mistake in over 60 games?
That will inspire the team yeah.
Just as well you dont pick the team.
Hall Of Fame
The hysteria on here is mental after Thursdays shambles. Back to basics on sunday and we will get the win. Lewis won’t play as bad again thats a certainty.
Lewis
Logan O’Connor Arnie Consi
Shinnie Tansey
Wright Christie Stewart
May.
That team will win and there is even a chance we will be top of the pile after the final whistle.
Hall Of Fame
Wouldn't be at all surprised if Reynolds replaced Consi and, unfortunately, can't see McLean being dropped. Think McInnes might go 4-4-1-1 so Tansey, McLean, Shinnie, Wright; Christie; May.
Hall Of Fame
Lewis
Logan AOC Arnason Shinnie
Tansey McLean
Stewart Christie Wright
May
A few concerns with that X1
- chronic lack of pace at centre half. Moult will like that
- Stewart is a lazy get & won't track back but so feckless is GMS I'd give him a go.
- is Tansey fit to start?
Hall Of Fame
You would really drop Lewis on the back of a bad performance??
I'm all for people having different opinions, but feck me min, Joe has saved us far more than cost us and has banked enough credit which would allow him a few more bad games to come before I would even consider dropping him.
SHinnie and Lewis are the only 2 of our current team we cannot drop. I would say Christie too, but we have to play games without him anyway, so we need to try other folk in his role.
Hall Of Fame
It's not clever psychologically to drop the goalie after one poor game( seeing as he done exceptionally in most matches) unless we drop the whole 11 which would be justified, if we had larger squad.
make the change after he has had another game or 2.
It's the manager I'd like to change though. Why can't he be dropped ( for assistant) after a few poor games like we do with players , stupid tradition I guess.
I really can't see anything other than another shambles. We have been ragged in every game this season imo
Posting Permissions