This years hall of fame,..

[jdfc]

Whose your pick, it’s Sinky for me all day long, maybe some of the older ones like shaded and Noah will go for Bobby Robinson, thoughts

[shaded]

yip trigger mate
altho a wee bit dissapointed that nae players fae the early years have been put forward(unless iv missed them)
guys like jock gilmour who made 369 appearances for the Club in 13 seasons including the 1925 Scottish Cup Final and his consistent performances earned him calls up to both the full National and Scottish League sides and he sits 11th on Dundee’s all-time appearance record. also captained the side

[Returnofrros]

yip trigger mate
altho a wee bit dissapointed that nae players fae the early years have been put forward(unless iv missed them)
guys like jock gilmour who made 369 appearances for the Club in 13 seasons including the 1925 Scottish Cup Final and his consistent performances earned him calls up to both the full National and Scottish League sides and he sits 11th on Dundee’s all-time appearance record. also captained the side

Cammy Fraser....em a sucker for a hard tackling midfielder.

[petermackie]

Read Toshs Derby record of 7 wins and 6 draws in the tully....thought that was incredible given how good the doon mob thought they were back then

[Shuntz]

For these things to actually matter then there has to be parameters on whch to judge these things

Things that should be taken into account should include

Number of appearances
Honours won
Caps won
Part of a unique team

To that end on the suggested inductees iBobby Robinson imo most closely meets my own criteria and he will get my vote

[jdfc]

It’s an age thing 😳

[Returnofrros]

For these things to actually matter then there has to be parameters on whch to judge these things

Things that should be taken into account should include

Number of appearances
Honours won
Caps won
Part of a unique team

To that end on the suggested inductees iBobby Robinson imo most closely meets my own criteria and he will get my vote

I think it should be left entirely up to the fans.

I wouldn't even have a shortlist, never mind criteria.

If your gonna have a popularity contest you may as well have a pure popularity contest.

The Bombers time is coming.☺

But your criteria isn't unreasonable.

[eric_sinclair]

All worthy nominees,only one legend tho.😉
Punch eez puss

[RAM1971]

Jim McLean would be a very apt contender, having both a successful playing career with the Dees as well as a coaching spell, skills which he very successfully transferred elsewhere, leading him to eventually becoming inducted into the Scottish Football Hall of Fame.

[Returnofrros]

Jim McLean would be a very apt contender, having both a successful playing career with the Dees as well as a coaching spell, skills which he very successfully transferred elsewhere, leading him to eventually becoming inducted into the Scottish Football Hall of Fame.

Think the numerous cases of bullying, making himself pretty wealthy on the back of a Scottish club, assaulting a member of the press on national tv ( how he got away with that, god only knows), the pre Bosman lifetime contracts for peanuts and the fact he was a moaning **** would count against him.

On the plus side almost took the dabs to the wall and sold to the Thompson's who are finishing the job.

Still em all for a free vote.