Derek McInnes

[hamishmclure]

So how did Graham potter manage to take a team from Sweden beat galatsry, then qualify from a group and also beat arsenal at emirates if it’s impossible to compete with money.

Nice one about Guardiola do you think he tells his team to go out and let the opposition have the ball ?

Considine popular in the dressing room didn’t tango say that about Derek young

1. I take your point but that's just such a niche, one-off example. We only lost out to Real Sociedad a wee while ago! Sometimes momentum carries you through, perhaps opposition teams didn't realise the threat, maybe they got lucky while we didn't. There are a heap of reasons but I'd argue us beating Celtic with that Hayes goal was as big a result, and getting close to La Real not far off it either. It happens a lot - look at Leicester in the Champions League the season after they won the title. Look at Middlesbrough reaching the UEFA Cup final while failing like numpties in domestic competition. With luck and momentum, we could well have reached group stages last summer. It certainly wasn't tactical or motivational reasons that let us down. Arsenal's reserve team are dreadful and lack any grit whatsoever - we would have beaten them.

2. Good een. No, but it's very difficult to play that style of football with footballers who aren't at the level to do it. Needs exceptional fitness, stamina and ability on the ball let alone understanding of positioning. Peter Bosz at Ajax did incredible job, it didn't work at Borussia Dortmund. That's not because the players were worse but perhaps because the playing staff needed a different approach and there wasn't time to learn that one.

3. Fair point about Derek Young but would argue Considine is slightly different case. Considine added a real threat from crosses sent to him from the right wing when he was at his peak, like a false target man who started at left back (lol). That was when we were allowed to be a counter-attacking side though. Have struggled to get similar delivery since Hayes and McGinn gone, and since Jack has gone. Jack's absence has meant the full-backs - particularly Shay - can't get forward as often or early as they'd like since nobody has control of the football in the midfield.

[rico94]

1. I take your point but that's just such a niche, one-off example. We only lost out to Real Sociedad a wee while ago! Sometimes momentum carries you through, perhaps opposition teams didn't realise the threat, maybe they got lucky while we didn't. There are a heap of reasons but I'd argue us beating Celtic with that Hayes goal was as big a result, and getting close to La Real not far off it either. It happens a lot - look at Leicester in the Champions League the season after they won the title. Look at Middlesbrough reaching the UEFA Cup final while failing like numpties in domestic competition. With luck and momentum, we could well have reached group stages last summer. It certainly wasn't tactical or motivational reasons that let us down. Arsenal's reserve team are dreadful and lack any grit whatsoever - we would have beaten them.

2. Good een. No, but it's very difficult to play that style of football with footballers who aren't at the level to do it. Needs exceptional fitness, stamina and ability on the ball let alone understanding of positioning. Peter Bosz at Ajax did incredible job, it didn't work at Borussia Dortmund. That's not because the players were worse but perhaps because the playing staff needed a different approach and there wasn't time to learn that one.

3. Fair point about Derek Young but would argue Considine is slightly different case. Considine added a real threat from crosses sent to him from the right wing when he was at his peak, like a false target man who started at left back (lol). That was when we were allowed to be a counter-attacking side though. Have struggled to get similar delivery since Hayes and McGinn gone, and since Jack has gone. Jack's absence has meant the full-backs - particularly Shay - can't get forward as often or early as they'd like since nobody has control of the football in the midfield.

Welcome aboard hamishmclure,I will give you a bit of advice,the locals round here think guff football is pysh so I wouldn’t keep using them as examples.

Ps Considine is shyte

[Basingstokered]

1. I take your point but that's just such a niche, one-off example. We only lost out to Real Sociedad a wee while ago! Sometimes momentum carries you through, perhaps opposition teams didn't realise the threat, maybe they got lucky while we didn't. There are a heap of reasons but I'd argue us beating Celtic with that Hayes goal was as big a result, and getting close to La Real not far off it either. It happens a lot - look at Leicester in the Champions League the season after they won the title. Look at Middlesbrough reaching the UEFA Cup final while failing like numpties in domestic competition. With luck and momentum, we could well have reached group stages last summer. It certainly wasn't tactical or motivational reasons that let us down. Arsenal's reserve team are dreadful and lack any grit whatsoever - we would have beaten them.

2. Good een. No, but it's very difficult to play that style of football with footballers who aren't at the level to do it. Needs exceptional fitness, stamina and ability on the ball let alone understanding of positioning. Peter Bosz at Ajax did incredible job, it didn't work at Borussia Dortmund. That's not because the players were worse but perhaps because the playing staff needed a different approach and there wasn't time to learn that one.

3. Fair point about Derek Young but would argue Considine is slightly different case. Considine added a real threat from crosses sent to him from the right wing when he was at his peak, like a false target man who started at left back (lol). That was when we were allowed to be a counter-attacking side though. Have struggled to get similar delivery since Hayes and McGinn gone, and since Jack has gone. Jack's absence has meant the full-backs - particularly Shay - can't get forward as often or early as they'd like since nobody has control of the football in the midfield.

Derek has never managed in the playoff round socidedad was the 3rd. He keeps losing to teams before the playoff round by his bottling.

You also say that rangers have better players than us and that Derek is ambitious so why hasn’t he gone to manage them if they’re better more chance of winning things. He’s more than happy to stick here where he can bottle every big game and Milne won’t care.

[hamishmclure]

Welcome aboard hamishmclure,I will give you a bit of advice,the locals round here think guff football is pysh so I wouldn’t keep using them as examples.

Ps Considine is shyte

[Jupiter]

It is working though. We are third and will hopefully finish second. Bringing up Fergie is mental - it's 2018! Do you think Pep Guardiola just tells his lads 'get stuck in eh'

Cannot believe some of the opinions on here suggesting Aberdeen are going backwards because we haven't won everything . McInnes may well have hit a ceiling but that's hardly his fault!

We went from mid-table rambling to 2nd best in Scotland, genuinely pushed Celtic until things (behind the scenes by all accounts) unraveled and have had to rebuild with a budget about 30x lower than Celtic and a scouting network about 100th of the size. This is not the 80s - football has changed everywhere and plenty bigger clubs than us have been left in the abyss. There is barely any interest in Scottish football, let alone Aberdeen, outside of Scotland and Aberdeen.

If, say, Claudio Ranieri - someone who achieved miracles - took over in the summer, do you think he'd win that league? Would he do any better than 2nd place? Kante, or Vardy or Mahrez - comparatively - don't exist in our squad. Christie doesn't even get a start for Celtic. Would Ranieri be able to attract the players capable of pushing Celtic, while paying them 1/10th of what Rodgers does? These players don't exist and the gap is far closer between teams down south in the top league than they are at home. There is no way of finishing first without better players.

If Arnason had converted that cross, if GMS had played a better ball to May, the result could have been totally different. McInnes got his setup right this time (and he's tried every way possible over those 10 games - shouldn't he be commended for trying different tactical styles than doing a Levein and defending 4-6-0?). Do you think we were that much better in the last game we won against Celtic because Hayes smashed a 30 yarder into the top corner? You can't plan for those types of goals!

Our best chance of success comes from cup competitions. They are knock-out games and the best team doesn't always win. Usually the luckiest, and most defensive, do. Portugal won Euro 2016, they were not the best team. McInnes is ambitious but realistic.

Aberdeen going backwards would be reverting to a top six finish at best. We are pushing for wins on all fronts but getting done when players don't turn up. McInnes knows that's not good enough, but what is he supposed to do? I really want to know what people who don't rate him think is the answer.

Considine is a leader, a dressing room favourite and has been loyal to the club. Yes, he's really dropped in quality this season (physical attributes especially), and yeh, you have to pay him accordingly, which means you're losing budget for a far better left-back. But what you get is a better dressing room, which helps yield better results and makes for a better club. There are ways to cut ties but his contract was signed while he was doing really well for us and if that was planned as part of the budget, there's little anyone can do. Tierney is a Champions League level player - there's nobody we could get close to that. We could sign someone on loan? But then they're arguably not as committed as someone whose job depends on winning. Best option is someone young and unproven, but then you lose experience and leadership in the dressing room. I do agree Considine needs replacing but think the way McInnes has handled the situation has been excellent.

Who are these magical mystery managers who will come in and finish top of the league? Or cruise to second? Beating Celtic to the league this season would require perfection in every game - over a league season that's impossible. We'd need Celtic players to have howlers - and be punished for it at least some of the time! Nobody beats Celtic.

As for pressing. Jeeeeeesus. Huddersfield is a good example. Their game is all about a high press and disrupting opponents with attacking football but guess what - when they play teams with much better players, they have to adapt because it's a suicide mission.

I agree it would be nice to see our players attack and beat the big teams, keep composure and cool, get stuck in and keep the ball - especially against the rangers - but the players on the books aren't good enough, and they likely won't be ever again. Money ruins all.

Saying McInnes is in his comfort zone is so wrong. This is a guy with huge ambition who wants to beat big targets with a limited squad. Steve Clarke might be doing well with Killie but they're sixth. Neil Lennon has done a great job with Hibs but they're fourth. If you think our players are better than Rangers then... well there is no hope.

Remember all those games in the 90s that we beat the Old Firm? Those were great days weren't they!

How much did McInnes pay you to write that?

[rico94]

Derek has never managed in the playoff round socidedad was the 3rd. He keeps losing to teams before the playoff round by his bottling.

You also say that rangers have better players than us and that Derek is ambitious so why hasn’t he gone to manage them if they’re better more chance of winning things. He’s more than happy to stick here where he can bottle every big game and Milne won’t care.

The Huns have spent £10 million on players this season as well as the loans they brought in January,I wouldn’t say they have all been a success but if you are spending that kind of money in the SPFL you are likely to end up with a better squad than most.

[donsdaft]

I’ve nae been one to slag McInnes but how did his thinking go on Sunday?

We’ll never match their midfield so let’s just not play any midfielders


He’s signed a fair few good players lately, shame they all play in the same position.

[Hairdrier]

How much did McInnes pay you to write that?

Possibly McInnes wrote it, or his agent/PR man/person.

[seeyazander]

Derek has never managed in the playoff round socidedad was the 3rd. He keeps losing to teams before the playoff round by his bottling.

You also say that rangers have better players than us and that Derek is ambitious so why hasn’t he gone to manage them if they’re better more chance of winning things. He’s more than happy to stick here where he can bottle every big game and Milne won’t care.

So basically hes in a "comfort zone", he knows his job is safe as long as the majority of results go his way along with a decent run in the cups. Two things missing at the club for god knows how long, Ability and Ambition, the need to speculate and bring in some decent players along with holding on to the likes of Hayes would go a long way to appeasing a support which is getting more disgruntled with every passing week, to lose tothe Huns 3 times this season without putting up a fight is probably the hardest thing to accept out of all of this, ability wise we have a bombscare defence which is no nearer to being sorted out than it was a couple of seasons ago, Arnason and McKenna were playing pretty decent together until Deek decided to change things again. On the subject of McKenna, we were told he wouldnt be sold in the last transfer window so does this mean he will be away at the end of this season.

[RED_JOHN]

A truly fantastic read.
Well said

A happy clappers dream that read.
What a lack of ambition and one that sums Derek McInnes up very nicely.
afc1903mad have big competition to fight your way to who is up Del’s @rse the most. Put a pair of wellies on as you are getting a bit deep!