You did a good job with this poll, Frog. It brought a bit of clarity to what hadn't been measured for a while and nobody could argue with that.
I actually thought you were onto something with your experimental approach to shelving the lengthier OT posts elsewhere in an attempt to allow football related ones to stay longer on the main page. Are you saying that in the end doing this didn't actually achieve your objective?
I would offer one piece of constructive feedback - and it's meant well. If you are going to experiment with moving OT posts in the middle of a poll to determine whether we do or don't need a separate OT board, make sure you tell everybody you're going to do it before you start and make it clear that this is just to try out a possible compromise solution.
(If you did do this, apologies - but I never saw anything and obviously a few others didn't either...)
I must say I was a bit miffed when I saw it but - after understanding what you were trying to do - fully supported the aim of the experiment, as you know.