The club promised an 'independent' enquiry in 2016 and so why didn't they do it?
That looks pretty bad unless you can think of a reason why a police investigation would be inferior to an independent one or are they in fact the same thing but in one regard perhaps better because the police have powers to investigate and interrogate and even arrest people that the other one can't? However, the difference could be that most independent enquiries have a prominent lawyer or QC leading them which be very costly anyway but the findings tend to be made public to give everyone confidence all the issues have been looked at and so is there any reason why the police investigations and their final report if that is what convinced the club that no further action is needed, is also made public?
If the club just say its been investigated by the police and that's the end of the matter, then its likely the pressure on them will just increase to have one. I did think they were having one as they said so and so once again, why did they not explain to the public and especially the victims and their families why they changed their minds? This club really does need to up its game in this regard. It's not as though they have been warned dozens of times they really do need to communicate far far better and not act like they are in a 100 feet underground bunker!