Paul Warnes signings

[millertop]

Palmer
Smith
Cummings
Onariase
Moore
Emmanuel
Rodak
Towell
Lavery
Williams
Ball
Proctor
Potter
Ihiekwe
Purrington
Bray
Ajayi
O’Donnell


That right?

[caytonmiller]

How many will be any good in the championship?
Palmer yes
Smith no
Cummings no
Onariase no
Moore no
Emmanuel yes
Rodak yes
Towell no
Lavery no
Williams yes
Ball no
Proctor yes
Potter yes
Ihiekwe yes
Purrington yes
Bray no
Ajayi yes
O’Donnell no

[Casper64Frank]

Disagree with you about David Ball and Richie Towell if he comes back.

[vespabri]

So do I Casper

[millertop]

I disagree with Smith and Ball

No comment on them that are not here

[caytonmiller]

I was humming and aaaring about ball. Great touch, good skills though when he uses these skills to get past defenders he doesn't have the pace to get away from them.. just feel championship STD defenders will keep him quite in game. Which in turn will dent his confidence.
Towell I've said a few times he takes too many touches n championship midfielders will over run him..
Smith. His main attribute is holding up the ball. He likes to bully the CB and with better quality defenders he won't be as effective.. he also needs 4/5 chances per game to get his goal. He's not guna get that in the championship...

If anyone would like to bake a humble pie I would be more than happy to scoff the lot

[sCORaFU]

Smith has a great touch for a big man and I think that he will cause problems. It really depends on how PW plays him. He may well be on his own in away matches, but that's one for the management team. The guy deserves the chance.

[welovebooth]

keiffer Moore no and towell no but Mr calamity ihiekwe yes .

I despair

[caytonmiller]

I wouldn't want my opinions to make you despair m8. Would it make you feel better if I changed my mind? You need a cuddle?

[flourbasher]

Just out of interest Cayton why do you think Ihiekwe will be ok in the C'ship?
Genuine question, not criticising
Is it the theory that some players are perhaps better suited to a higher division for example Semi appeared to fare better in the C'ship