Dundee fans

[Returnofrros]

Expectation levels are v high, over the top reaction after 5 games.

.still interesting reading that NM isn't interested in Dundee, haber was great and obviously committed to Dundee and shankland is a bargain.

World's going mad.

[noahrab]

Never heard NM isn’t interested in DFC.

No ones said Haber was great just a better option for the team than Moussa.

No one knows if any players a bargain until we’ve signed and played him and seen his worth to the team.

You need to stop all this drama queen stuff.

[Returnofrros]

Never heard NM isn’t interested in DFC.

No ones said Haber was great just a better option for the team than Moussa.

No one knows if any players a bargain until we’ve signed and played him and seen his worth to the team.

You need to stop all this drama queen stuff.

1.On another thread.

2.Haber wasn't interested

3. If we spend close to a quarter of a million on shankland it would be utter madness.

A smaller much smaller fee and bigger add ons if we were to take such a huge gamble.....seems to me McCall is playing us.

And I repeat expectation levels far too high.

[noahrab]

1.On another thread.

2.Haber wasn't interested

3. If we spend close to a quarter of a million on shankland it would be utter madness.

A smaller much smaller fee and bigger add ons if we were to take such a huge gamble.....seems to me McCall is playing us.

And I repeat expectation levels far too high.

Is it too much to ask the manager learns from his obvious mistakes?

[Shuntz]

Expectations are not high with me

Based on the current players and playing style

I expect another brutal season which could easily end with the drop

[noahrab]

Expectations are not high with me

Based on the current players and playing style

I expect another brutal season which could easily end with the drop

Certainly a worse squad than last season.

2 or 3 players could make all the difference.

[Returnofrros]

Is it too much to ask the manager learns from his obvious mistakes?

No.....but managers make mistakes.....he is the most committed Dundee manager I've seen in a long while.

I accept that it's his team, his judgement, his tactics but it's also his job so he has to do it as he sees fit. By most accounts we played reasonably well yesterday and a point was the least we deserved....we missed a pen and the keeper made a howler.

I'd suggest let's see where we are after first quarter.....bottom two heat is on but I don't think we will be.

And shankland would need balls of steel to play here if we pay 250k.....Hamilton got 1 game and holt was hounded for two years.

[ProvieRd]

No.....but managers make mistakes.....he is the most committed Dundee manager I've seen in a long while.

I accept that it's his team, his judgement, his tactics but it's also his job so he has to do it as he sees fit. By most accounts we played reasonably well yesterday and a point was the least we deserved....we missed a pen and the keeper made a howler.

I'd suggest let's see where we are after first quarter.....bottom two heat is on but I don't think we will be.

And shankland would need balls of steel to play here if we pay 250k.....Hamilton got 1 game and holt was hounded for two years.

What makes you say he’s committed? More than any other recent manager?

[Returnofrros]

What makes you say he’s committed? More than any other recent manager?

I'll make an exception for Barry Smith.

Ph was always a good run away from leaving it was mostly about ph rather than the club.

The Bombers connections with another club (cant mind which one&#128521 was always gonna make him short term.

Gordon Chisholm and the ****ebag....enough said.

Jocky Scott was suspicious and a bit world weary by his 3rd stint.

Alex Rae shud have got a bit longer but knives were oot for him and never really won the body of the Kirk over and was more committed to being a summariser for rangers European games.

I think McCann is committed to the club in at least the medium term....gave up very good job, his attitude when he lost his dad, willingness to engage with supporters and not forgetting playing for us during defiant season.

I honestly think he craves a trophy as much as any fan and deserves much more leeway than he's getting.

Wolters was a howler of a signing, Moussa hasn't set the heather on fire but no way comes into the Wolters category, Hamilton was possibly uneccesary but plenty wanted parish bombed ( not me) and letting holt go was an error imho but most would disagree with that.

I think he's done ok, do I want him to do better yes, do I think Neil McCann wants to do better and push himself to do better yes.

Will he eventually get sacked or
walk...quite possibly.

It just seems to me that to a lot of fans nobody's good enough.

Hamilton.....****e
Parish....****e
Holt.....****e
McGowan....****e
Kamara....dosenae score
Kerr odea Spence deacon Meekings Waddell ksunga ****e ****ey and ****ier.

Cw33 gets a bit o leeway...no much mind you.

[Deeranged]

Is it too much to ask the manager learns from his obvious mistakes?

So far in McCann's short managerial career it certainly seems way too much to ask of him.