Lewis Ferguson Tribunal

[thebeachend]

Imagine ****1ng it having to pay for a sellable asset. Pay it and put him on a 4yr deal immediately.

[Pacman1903]

Kishnashvilli couldnt have had a tribunal. He wasnt a Dundee youth player

[redtaz]

good reasoned post , you will receive criticism, your not really allowed to post this way ,
however he has played well above expectations since arriving here we maybe should have left him playing with 21s until after tribunal as they are obviously pinning their hopes on his most recent performances

[redtaz]

Its not going to be £1.2M.
Its Showmanship, thats all.
If they valued him like that when he was at the club, they would have had him on a much better, longer contract.

oops should have been attached to this post

[Basingstokered]

good reasoned post , you will receive criticism, your not really allowed to post this way ,
however he has played well above expectations since arriving here we maybe should have left him playing with 21s until after tribunal as they are obviously pinning their hopes on his most recent performances

Good reasoned post aye okay. Hamilton have the right to place any value they like in fact anyone selling anything has that right suppose you’d sell your house for a below what you believe it to be worth.

Next you’ll be telling us that we should accept 500k for McKenna and that we should t be anywhere near 10m

[afc1903mad]

Kishnashvilli couldnt have had a tribunal. He wasnt a Dundee youth player

Didn’t think it had to be.

[afc1903mad]

good reasoned post , you will receive criticism, your not really allowed to post this way ,
however he has played well above expectations since arriving here we maybe should have left him playing with 21s until after tribunal as they are obviously pinning their hopes on his most recent performances

I believe there is a formula that’s defines the value.
I also read somewhere that they go with whoever has set the closest value to stop massive undervaluing and over valuing of players.
In essence to hope that the clubs are close to an agreement.

[afc1903mad]

Good reasoned post aye okay. Hamilton have the right to place any value they like in fact anyone selling anything has that right suppose you’d sell your house for a below what you believe it to be worth.

Next you’ll be telling us that we should accept 500k for McKenna and that we should t be anywhere near 10m

The difference being Ferguson was out of contract

[Basingstokered]

The difference being Ferguson was out of contract

They can still place any value on him they want

[afc1903mad]

They can still place any value on him they want

Indeed, but doesn’t mean they’re correct and they couldn’t stop him moving on.