Manning or Towell?

[frogmiller]

I enjoyed watching Towell energise our team last season but I'm delighted with the signing of Manning.

I can only see Manning getting better as he gets more game time. The only fear I have is that we end up in a keifer Moore situation and he gets recalled by QPR and then sold.

Out of the two I would go for Manning.

[millertop]

Manning.

Forget about Towell Warney, move on and get another player

[rolymiller]

Think towell may regret not coming here. It's like you say millertop. We need to move on anyway and get a different style of midfielder more frexish. I would be surprised if he is happy to rot in brightons reserves but if he is happy to do that just allegedly for money then he ain't a warney player anyway.

[CASPER-64-FRANK]

Ryan Manning for me.
We've met our impasse on Towell and failed so far, time to move on. RT may still be injured from late July which could be a reason why no other clubs have signed him yet. He won't want to play reserve team football.

Another youngster to look at....Todd Cantwell from Norwich, midfielder , not certain Norwich would allow him out on loan. TC was on loan at Dutch side Fortuna Sittard from January to end of last season.

It's a long while till January especially with the small squad of players we have.

[great_fire]

Still need another midfielder and a left-back.

[Monkey46]

We do need to strengthen mid field but forget Towell now he aint coming.

[dmentor]

I'm a big Richie Towell fan,to be honest,i wish we had them both,Manning is a very good player.

[mellowmiller]

Ryan Manning for me and forget about Towell. They are too similar in style anyway and we need a midfield destroyer now.
The problem with all of this is that none of these players are ours and our midfield could be ripped apart in January.
It's a dangerous game building a key area of the team on foundations of sand.

[flourbasher]

Surely it's not as simple as one or the other.
What if RM gets injured or a straight red card or hits a dip in form
Even though it's a season long loan he might be recalled in Jan.
Either way it's a long season

[Pattylallacks2]

Towell at NYS this afternoon. You heard it here first