McKinnon

[Returnofrros]

Irrelevant. Nelms is paid near 200k to make and take those decisions. St Mirren properly researched the market and appointed the best candidate for them. Even if it doesn't work out in the long term, they showed how it's done. It's Miller, anyway, isn't it.

Hope not.

Need expirience.

Wouldn't want Hughes, dodds (****), Duffy or Robertson.

Neilsen no sure, Stubbs same, Mcpake no experience.

Danny Lennon? Ian McCall, John Robertson all have down sides.

Peter houston....he'd say no, same with Wright.

Anybodies guess really but I'd go with as much expirience as they can get.

One window won't be enough to sort this out so we need someone to get us above st m and accies.

Organised and harder to beat is the best route.

[Taintedice]

Livi pulled Holt out of somewhere, there are agencies who could help Nelms who actually saw what Jack Ross was about but still went for McCann.

[Returnofrros]

Livi pulled Holt out of somewhere, there are agencies who could help Nelms who actually saw what Jack Ross was about but still went for McCann.

Yep agree.

I've just not commented on people I know little about.

[Taintedice]

Miller has been brought in to take over, perhaps supported by McPake? Why else give him a 2-year deal at his age? Miller also captain today, how much does McCann hate that dressing room!

[deecom]

What about Barry smith on a tempoary basis until we find a suitable manager ?

[Returnofrros]

What about Barry smith on a tempoary basis until we find a suitable manager ?

Pros and cons again imho but we wouldn't go down for the lack of effort with him in charge.

[Taintedice]

Unfortunately not, too much pressure already on any replacement. Needs someone whose been down this path before and turned a club around.

As for McKinnon, leading 2-0 at half-time, loses 3-2

[ABERFELDYDEE]

Irrelevant. Nelms is paid near 200k to make and take those decisions. St Mirren properly researched the market and appointed the best candidate for them. Even if it doesn't work out in the long term, they showed how it's done. It's Miller, anyway, isn't it.

But Tainted on another thread under one of your other names you scoffed at Dundee getting relegated and said i was pished
changed your mind now?

[Taintedice]

Aye ok bud.

[noahrab]

Who do you want?

Who don't you want?

Jim Gooodwin.