Reply With QuoteIt’s not a position McInnes cares about, so neither should anyone else
International
after attending the game on saturday i think andys days are possibly numbered i was impressed by the boy lowe , also whilst andy does ok at centre back i think he has difficulty playing with scott , i noted the number of times he had to clear or pass the ball with his right , not his favoured option and it placed him under unnecessary pressure
Joe has to think of this when putting it out too him when in my view he could just have punted it up to where it inevitably ended .
i am not having a go at andy at all its just his teammates were not recognising his frailties in this
Lowe however must have done a shoulder workout the amount of times he appeared " free" and was not sent the ball his arms waving in the air
as always views and opinions will no doubt differ , but its good to debate and see others views even although theyme at times
Last edited by redtaz; 18-09-2018 at 02:45 PM. Reason: i
Hall Of Fame
It’s not a position McInnes cares about, so neither should anyone else
Hall Of Fame
Quality
International
:d:d:d:d:dOriginally Posted by mason89
Hall Of Fame
Shinnie is the best left back at the club hands down. We don’t need him in a sitting midfielder position as the majority of our opponents play negative football anyway.after attending the game on saturday i think andys days are possibly numbered i was impressed by the boy lowe , also whilst andy does ok at centre back i think he has difficulty playing with scott , i noted the number of times he had to clear or pass the ball with his right , not his favoured option and it placed him under unnecessary pressure
Joe has to think of this when putting it out too him when in my view he could just have punted it up to where it inevitably ended .
i am not having a go at andy at all its just his teammates were not recognising his frailties in this
Lowe however must have done a shoulder workout the amount of times he appeared " free" and was not sent the ball his arms waving in the air
as always views and opinions will no doubt differ , but its good to debate and see others views even although they
Get him in at left back with Logan at right back and Devlin and McKenna as the central defence. A midfield of GMS, Ferguson, Wright and Ross, Upfront McGinn and Anderson. Joe Lewis will be kept quiet in goals as we will be banging them in for a change.
Hall Of Fame
I’m very impressed with Lowe at LB, Shinnie can stay in his best position in midfieldShinnie is the best left back at the club hands down. We don’t need him in a sitting midfielder position as the majority of our opponents play negative football anyway.
Get him in at left back with Logan at right back and Devlin and McKenna as the central defence. A midfield of GMS, Ferguson, Wright and Ross, Upfront McGinn and Anderson. Joe Lewis will be kept quiet in goals as we will be banging them in for a change.
Reserve
Shinnie doesn't want to play Left Back - in a contract year it would be foolish to wind him up by playing him there when he wants to play centre midfield - he's also got Scotland intentions and that's never happening at Left Back.Shinnie is the best left back at the club hands down. We don’t need him in a sitting midfielder position as the majority of our opponents play negative football anyway.
Get him in at left back with Logan at right back and Devlin and McKenna as the central defence. A midfield of GMS, Ferguson, Wright and Ross, Upfront McGinn and Anderson. Joe Lewis will be kept quiet in goals as we will be banging them in for a change.
Hall Of Fame
Why the big concern about him playing for Scotland?
Let’s look after Aberdeen first and foremost...Shinnie is the best left back in our squad and should be deployed there. Absolutely no need for him as a sitting midfielder at times.
Lewis
Logan Devlin McKenna Shinnie
Ross Wright Ferguson GMS
McGinn Anderson
This team will up our goals tally. F@ck negative football with a team built around 2 sitting midfielders and players who’s first intention is to defend. Goals are entertaining....Watching Gleeson, Forrester, Ball, Cosgrove, Considine etc would make your eyes bleed.
Last edited by RED_JOHN; 18-09-2018 at 07:42 PM.
Reserve
I'm not concerned about him playing for Scotland. If you read what I said, SHINNIE will be concerned about playing for Scotland. He's just made the squad, he prefers playing centre midfield and his contract is up at the end of the reason.
Yes he will do a good job at Left Back, but you could also unsettle him and he leaves since that isn't where he wants to play for the rest of his career.
I agree with your comments regarding team formation and attacking, to be honest I think Shinnie's position is the least of our worries. McInnes would play Gleeson, Ball and Shinnie as a holding 3 if he could get away with it.
Hall Of Fame
McInnes can’t get enough defensive players in his team selections at times. His first thought is always to stop the opposition and hopefully hit on the counter when they open up. We should try a more positive approach like I suggest, might be entertaining instead of absolute dross.
Posting Permissions