The referees' forum which I frequent are in agreement that Kompany should have gone, the second goal was terrible officiating and Sane should have been booked, the ball was out of play and the player was offside and Sane should have been off for hos assault on Lowton. They thought that City had been handed a large slice of luck with decisions in their favour today and agreed with Sean Dyche's comments.
Dyche is getting the reputation amongst ex pros and press as a whinger. Its way better than his repetitive sales patter we have suffered for 5 years.
Nobody cares what a refs forum says.
Its the interpretation of the referee on the day from what he sees. No one else.
Could have, should have, would haves don't roll with me.
Ps. We hardly kicked the ball. Dyche didn't have much claret to talk.
Wake up people our defence cost 10€ million
That's all five!!!!!
Even the muppets on MOTD agreed that Dyche was right to feel aggrieved, their second was such a shambles that even the liner has apologised for getting it wrong, and City should have finished the game with nine men if the ref had done his job properly. Dyche admitted none of it affected the outcome, and maybe it didn't, but it would have been interesting to see City playing virtually the entire game with ten men. Would they still have won ? I think they probably would, so maybe it's as well Kompany stayed on.
The second goal could have been prevented if just one of our players had been professional and followed the ball instead of showboating to the referee-simple.
Yes, Dyche said that, they switched off and they shouldn't have done. It would also have been prevented if the officials had been professional and done their job properly. So agreement all round, and everyone agrees it made no difference to the outcome, so no controversy at all really, storm in a tea cup.
.
....he's entitled to have a go at the officials - but he pointedly acknowledged City's quality....so essentialy, we were done for, and Burnley had absolutely nothing to offer in response - and I even think, that if City went down to 9 men - we'd still have struggled...regardless of the officiating - thats the reality, and that's what need to be addressed !
I would love to believe that he will work it out Supersub6 but if it is a problem of personnel he can do nothing until the Jan transfer window.
Of course, we had the very long pre-season transfer window and little was done except get an injured player in--so form doesn't support your upbeat.
If its NOT personnel why isn't it already sorted?