Originally Posted by
jackal2
As much as I understand the sentiment of this thread, past experiences make me cynical about this idea of fans "mobilising" and/or "taking their club back".
We did this with the help of Haydn Green many years ago, when the Trust took control after the club was rescued from the very brink of extinction. There was lots of well-meaning talk that this must never happen again and that the club in future would be a community-owned club that lived within its means, signed local players and appreciated the joy of existing more than demanding success. I've still got the brochure with the two magpies hatching a chick on the front cover under a headline saying 'A New Beginning'.
This 'New Beginning' ideal lasted about six to twelve months, when it became clear that living within your means actually meant a constant struggle at the bottom end of League Two and possibly worse. Howard Wilkinson amongst others departed, claiming the "business model couldn't work", which in truth was code for "you can't run a football club like any other business".
Of course, there is nothing written in the stars which says you can't run a football club sustainably. Nobody forces you to spend more on wages than you earn in revenue. It just means fans must adjust their expectations downwards by significant degree, but that just doesn't happen in football, at least not for long. Sure enough, within about two years of Trust ownership the masses were moaning about the club showing "no ambition" and needing to "speculate to accumulate" and all the other meaningless guff supporters come out with when they really just mean they want instant and ideally constant success and big name signings. Consequently, bitterness and acrimony ensued within the Trust itself, between those clinging on to the purist ideal and those who were sick of bottom of the league drudgery.
It was when that mindset became established that over 90% of the fanbase voted to give away Supporters Trust control to Munto finance, and the rest is history. Since 2010, we have had no real control over our club, we've just looked towards rich (or not so rich) individuals to bankroll our dreams, mostly without success.
And let's face it, even if the supporters somehow did seize back control of the club and committed to all those Trust ideals again, the exact same thing would happen, because football fans don't want to face financial reality, they want to live the dream. It's their escape from the real world. And the pursuit of that dream is such a risky thing that it can turn into a nightmare.
I'm not saying it's right. I'm not saying it's wrong. It just is what it is. We live in hope of a genuine benefactor who really can bankroll our success, but there are plenty of fraudsters out there looking for people like us, who will believe anything based on even the flimsiest evidence, because we desperately want to believe.