Man Management

[hmac]

Jack Hamilton has maybe his best game in the Dark blue (or whatever colour he picks) and we get a replacement in days later.

Just add it to the list James.

[Returnofrros]

Any lifeboat will do when your drowning, even if it means others get the push.

23 days ago "happy with the squad".....20 ****ing 3

[num1adi]

Badly needing a keeper , nothing wrong with today's signing

[BCram]

Jack Hamilton has maybe his best game in the Dark blue (or whatever colour he picks) and we get a replacement in days later.

Just add it to the list James.

Hamiltons 3rd goal against Motherwell was probably the reason for the loan activity. People still think Hamilton is a liability.

[Dee_Dee]

Hamilton saved us from a hammering against Dunfermline but it is good to get another decent keeper in

[hmac]

Badly needing a keeper , nothing wrong with today's signing

We all saw it should have been earlier, like last summer!

[BCram]

Any lifeboat will do when your drowning, even if it means others get the push.

23 days ago "happy with the squad".....20 ****ing 3

It's the January window. Moved on McPake, Todd and Mackie which seemed to be in tune with mood of supporters. Johnson attracting attention, Dorrans signs 18m contract, signs winger, bigger midfielder and loan goalie. Also, seems to me that if you want to make changes to do exactly as McPake has done. You express your support for the squad before an important Cup match in the expectation that they get the message and go for it.

I realise that posters want to give reasons for their views and I am not disputing what you have said, merely trying to show a different interpretation of the facts and why there might be sensible reasons for the change.

[hmac]

It's the January window. Moved on McPake, Todd and Mackie which seemed to be in tune with mood of supporters. Johnson attracting attention, Dorrans signs 18m contract, signs winger, bigger midfielder and loan goalie. Also, seems to me that if you want to make changes to do exactly as McPake has done. You express your support for the squad before an important Cup match in the expectation that they get the message and go for it.

I realise that posters want to give reasons for their views and I am not disputing what you have said, merely trying to show a different interpretation of the facts and why there might be sensible reasons for the change.

Todd never got a fair crack, McPake was injured and mackie was a nightmare he brought in! Johnson didn’t attract attention he walked off from training in the huff, a winger that’s not played at any decent level, the midfielder looks ok but he’s about the 9th we’ve tried in there.

3 weeks ago he said he was happy with his squad, your cup interpretation seems reasonable except we were shyte.

I’m sorry but the mgr has no trust left here, and neither does his boss

[BCram]

Todd never got a fair crack, McPake was injured and mackie was a nightmare he brought in! Johnson didn’t attract attention he walked off from training in the huff, a winger that’s not played at any decent level, the midfielder looks ok but he’s about the 9th we’ve tried in there.

3 weeks ago he said he was happy with his squad, your cup interpretation seems reasonable except we were shyte.

I’m sorry but the mgr has no trust left here, and neither does his boss

Fair rebuttal. Will just have to wait and see how things turn out.

[hmac]

Fair rebuttal. Will just have to wait and see how things turn out.

For the sake of Dundee Football Club I hope I am very very wrong