I don't get to any games now but in my time I've seen many of the goalkeepers mentioned on here and they all had their strong points (although I was never really impressed with Rod Jones) but my favourite, particularly when it came to bravery, was Alan Hill. And it wasn't just us who thought so. I was at a Forest v Everton match at the City Ground after we'd sold them Alan Hill and Barry Lyons. "You can have Barry Lyons back anytime," said a Forest fan when he discovered I was a Rotherham fan, "but if you've got any more like Alan Hill we'll have them." (In fairness to Barry Lyons whose wing play I really enjoyed at Millmoor, I think we had the best out of him before we sold him to Forest.)
I forgot to mention Bobby Mimms. Premier league winner (as much as Scott Carson)
I don’t really remember his first spell.
I think I can recall maybe 2/3 errors in his time here.
Every week there is a world class save.
Ive never enjoyed watching a player in a miller's shirt as much as I have watching him.
We've had good keepers in the 20 years I've followed us.
Hard to judge different eras and styles. He is an excellent keeper.
My favourite from the past , has to be Bobby Mimms. He was very unlucky that there as a lot of strong English goalies at the time when he was playing with Everton.
There's a certain World Cup winner between the sticks at Villa who was particularly special. I realise he was loaned to us but he deserves a mention. That said, I think Victor is better!