Walsall Ratings

[maddogslater]

Taking your post at it's fundamental level I agree with you that we are desperate for a controlling figure in the defence (be that the keeper or an outfield player). People have said Cameron is a leader! is he bolloxs! I haven't seen anyone in that back line screaming at others and telling/directing them. We need a voice, a loud one!

If its any consolation Cameron was giving Stone a right *******ing second half.

[SmiffyPie]

If its any consolation Cameron was giving Stone a right *******ing second half.

And he deserved it.

[LincsPie]

Olly Scott - second from the left. Looks like a 'Scott' we have.

Attachment 25403

Played for Kings Lynn, was in the squad playing against us Boxing Day 2021 apparently. Also played for Blyth Spartans and Consett.

[VerybigpieLittlepie]

We could just use the formation Williams used before joining us which just so happens to also fit each player in their positions they played before joining us
433 with 3up top
LS Langstaff
CS Didzy
RS Jones
AM Crowley
Cm Bostock
Cm whoever
Lb chicks
Rb macari
Cb Cameron
Cb Baldwin
Gk brooks
Having nemane on the bench means we might actually be able to make a sub that has a positive impact in the game too

[TSANHO]

We could just use the formation Williams used before joining us which just so happens to also fit each player in their positions they played before joining us
433 with 3up top
LS Langstaff
CS Didzy
RS Jones
AM Crowley
Cm Bostock
Cm whoever
Lb chicks
Rb macari
Cb Cameron
Cb Baldwin
Gk brooks
Having nemane on the bench means we might actually be able to make a sub that has a positive impact in the game too

I like the idea but neither Macari or Chicksen really suit that formation….and Brooks? He looked real dodgy in the games he played for us, has anyone seen him since? If he can’t get in the team now then I fear he never will.

Perhaps TAR at RB in a 4-3-3/4-2-3-1. In fact Cameron at LB in either formation would work better too with Macari partnering Baldwin in the middle.

…………Slocombe/Stone/Brooks (does it matter?!)


TAR………..Macari……….Baldwin………Cameron


…………………..….Bostock
…….Crowley……………………….JOB


Macca……….……….Didzy…………………Jones


CM is still very weak with very few options. Is Crowley capable of the work rate and strength required in that position? Dunno.