Fair does Sinkov - Tarky imo anyway is a good solid centre back but doesn’t have the potential or talent Beyer has.
Tarky is nearly 32 and Beyer 23 a lot of football / progress / experience happens in those years - I think Beyer has a big future in the game he’s two footed carries the ball and picks a pass - he’s weaker in the air though.
Tarky is vastly under-rated as a footballer imo, just because he's a big strong lad doesn't mean he can't play football, he can, with the best of them. An incredibly talented footballer, he'd have no problem playing midfield, in fact I've seen him do it for Burnley, in his first season, looked like he'd played there all his life.
To be honest, I've never thought of comparing Beyer to Tarky, he might get up to his level one day, but at the moment he's nowhere near. Just my opinion army, you're entitled to yours.
All this talk of last season...
Vk rolled a good dice and got City/Chelsea/Southampton quality players on loan, the players we loaned are European cup standard players, wanting a season with VK who offered first team games.
VK didn't bloody create them. Maatson is being linked to Dortmund..
Well done to VK for having first season pull, and city links.
Those loan players are the root cause of the current problem, and we had to sign those because of the fire sale of players instigated by Mr Pace and ALK. We would have had to spend £60-£80 million in summer to sign them, £60-£80 million just to stand still, and that was never going to be an option, so instead of standing still, we've gone backwards. But this is a result of the financial straitjacket Mr Pace has put us in, nothing to do with the manager.
We have all watched Alan Pace sanction over £100 million spends on mid-summer acquisitions. The money was there, why spend £9 million on O'Shea when we could have had THB for £15 million?
I know you dislike ALK but the money Pace has put on the table hardly justifies your statement about a "financial straitjacket Mr Pace has put us in". Remember when we went totally mad and bought Dale Stephens for a million quid?
I do not have a clue about who is actually choosing the players but it sounds a lot like if Kompany wants, Kompany gets.
I remember him and Bellamy being in Belgium to watch Foster, next day we had spunked £10 million and a player suffering with mental health issues was in Gawthorpe.
I also recall both you and me being horrified at the Dyche/Garlick recruitment policy. Those two make this lot like absolute amateurs.
Perhaps Mike Rigg was not that bad after all?
Attachment 25430