Broadfoot - Opinions?

[KillieKingdom]

Been debating with another fan on Twitter about Kirk Broadfoot, with regard to his rough tackle on a Dons player that lead to a penalty, which in the end cost us a semi-final place. The other fan tells me to get off his back, the guys been great and we lose - we go out together. This may be the case but what about the other players? If Killie were playing their best tonight then going out of the cup, is a waste of their effort.

UPDATE: Just seen the highlights and I am actually not sure now whether it was a penalty or not? The Dons player seemed to go down too easily while simultaneously, the slightest touch from Broadfoot could indicate that he may have pushed him.

What do you think of him?

[Speedy200]

I think he has been good so far but think his tackle was foolish,even although I think the Dons player went down to easy.Stevie should put the boys through a penalty workout as I was not impressed with the quality of our kicks.A school kid could have done better than two of the missed chances.