Jim Goodwin.

Robbie was big on everyone at the club being in it together, then jumped ship, how would anyone be able to take him serious again as the head of your club, everything he would say second time would just sound fake.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by the_arab

Goodwin said what the fans wanted to hear which is why so many like him.

He has called out errors, hinted at individuals and dropped players . You could argue the case that he lost the dressing room even more than any other manager did given the last 4 games and thats likely due to his comments. The players probably knew what Goodwin thought of them, that their days were numbered and no matter what they did would be shipped out.

Would this squad have done this to every manager? quite likely but what this squad certainly did not need is an openly critical manager giving them even more excuses to down tools.

Ultimately Goodwin, like the others got it wrong but then there was in all likelihood no right with this squad

---

Did he though? He came out and said we were making the same errors, week in week out, which we were. Everyone could see it. The players knew it. He very rarely blamed individuals until the Birighitti f*ck up last week. If that's a fault in a manager then we're f*cked employing anyone.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ianharab

Don’t get how anyone can blame Goodwin , for me , he done well to keep that shower in contention , says it all 3 different managers in 1 season it’s defo on the players , Ogren and Asghar . Don’t think wee Jim , Fergie or Pep could have done any better with that lot

---

Wee Jim would have battered a few of the c*nts for a start. JG is not escaping criticism as far as I'm concerned.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by the_arab

He has a worse win % than Fox, had 4 more games in charge than Ross (6 more in the league). The other teams doing their worst did more to keep our hopes up than Goodwin did, he has to shoulder some blame. he chose to stick with the keeper and mulgrew. those decisions cost us

---

The alternative a rookie keeper who has shipped 30 goals in 10 appearances for Peterhead/ Untied this season.

The alternative to Mulgrew? Ryan Edwards a player in terrible form who cost us goals especially against Aberdeen a game we actually played reasonably well in.

Not JG fault he was left with these poor choices.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by tHeArAb

Did he though? He came out and said we were making the same errors, week in week out, which we were. Everyone could see it. The players knew it. He very rarely blamed individuals until the Birighitti f*ck up last week. If that's a fault in a manager then we're f*cked employing anyone.

---

JG’s ultimately not very bright - he did the same with us and the players downed tools, but alas he never seems to learn. I think you’ll need to bin him to stand any chance next season.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by arab777

The alternative a rookie keeper who has shipped 30 goals in 10 appearances for Peterhead/ Untied this season.

The alternative to Mulgrew? Ryan Edwards a player in terrible form who cost us goals especially against Aberdeen a game we actually played reasonably well in.

Not JG fault he was left with these poor choices.

---

He took the job knowing that we were shyte, he knew the squad choices before he signed on, if he didn't then that's his own fault. I don't get how he's still the people's choice tbh

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Shetland Don

JG’s ultimately not very bright - he did the same with us and the players downed tools, but alas he never seems to learn. I think you’ll need to bin him to stand any chance next season.

---

I'm not sure we will. However I'm not sure he's good enough for the Premiership. It's worth noting that both successors in his previous two jobs have gone on to do better than him in this league.

It shows the soft as sh*te state of football players these days when they can't take a bit of criticism.

I don’t know if Goodwin is the answer, people wanting to give him a contract after 3 wins crazy, but damage was done/rot set before he arrived. Don’t think anyone could salvage the mess we were in due to recruitment.

Spot on JUSTaway that January window killed us off , recruitment has been woeful , Goodwin was farting against thunder

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Arabdownsouth

I don't disagree but I still don't think he's done enough to get the job. The last 4 games we've gone down without a whimper, no fight nothing! I'm sorry but a manager has to get more from his players. He didn't get anything from a better pool of players at Aberdeen either. It's a no from me.

---

Hard to see us attracting any manager of quality unfortunately.
Once upon a time maybe.
How about a McIntyre / Dodds combo 😊