Waters had a very good cameo and he gave us a glimpse of what might happen in the future, but 'swallows and summer' etc: it's far too early to tell.
He's young, he will make mistakes, he may look solid, but a few unpleasant and physical challenges will probably put him off his stride. If he gets thrown into this 2-month dog fight and comes out in May with a Div 1 team, then he deserves a medal. Until then I will hold fire and watch him develop.