Hmmmmm, not sure how much of this is fiction or baiting to be honest, but in a positive spirit, it is a tough question with the current team due to its form.
GMS is always exciting but not consistent
Shinnie is very commited but even his standards are lower this year.
McKenna has certainly grown as a player and very important to the team.
I'll probably go for Ferguson as his performances have exceeded expectations and form of those around him.
McGinn is nowhere near the favourite player on current form.
I'm struggling to think of many (just a couple) of fine performances he has had since he returned.
He wouldn't get in my starting 11 on current form.