First of all let me say that I did not watch last night so I cannot comment on any individual performance but what I can comment on is our defending at Oakwell so far this season & the word dreadful is the first word that comes into my head , for the 4th time this season we have concede 3 goals in a home game & we are only in the first week of Novemebr , I have pointed out in other threads that we have lost an entire back 3 that took us to a whisker of promotion & replaced them with potential , in fact it is worse than that as one of the replacements is a full back who should be playing at full back , we have no commanding defenders & no leadership which is frankly not good enough , now there are opinions on this forum that suggest we have replaced the departures with quality well I am sorry at this stage that is wrong , also some are of the opinion that we are competing for automatic promotion , again with our defence as it is there is absolutely no chance of the autos , now maybe a change of formation or a change of personnel in the team might solve the problem but to be fair our new head coach is showing that he is also a rookie & tactically he like the new players is learning his trade , therefore I can only conclude that a top half finish might be on the cards but with defending like we have been displaying then promotion or even play offs is beyond our capabilities . Footnote ; well done to Horsham and their fans .