
Originally Posted by
ragnarok
I can see both sides of the argument with regards to McInnes but it would be viewed as objectively crazy to get rid of him as manager after another 2nd place finish. I share the frustration at bottling the big games but I think you have to give credit where credit is due for the team's league performance, especially in the last two seasons when Mason's "we did well in a league without the Huns, Hearts and Hibs" argument doesn't hold water.
To put things into some perspective, the huns finished the season with 73 and 72 points respectively in 05/06 and 06/07 in the same league format. Neither of those were vintage hun teams by any stretch of the imagination but the reality is that those teams were assembled on a far higher budget than what is available to our current management team. The h*ns have spent a comparative fortune this season and those past seasons would suggest that we could easily spend three or four times our current budget poorly and not see any significant increase in performance. Even Hearts only managed 74 points in 05/06 and they were paying big wages for guys like Skacel, Jankauskas and Fyssas and already had a solid spine with guys like Gordon, Webster, Priscilla and Hartley.
I understand. Calls for realism fall flat after a gutless performance against a poor hun team, capitulation to the tims or another cup disappointment. I'm not suggesting that McInnes shouldn't take the flak he has received for those results. But some perspective is also required. We have a decent wage budget so can attract players who are better than the average player in our league but we are still rummaging around the bargain bins. Folk also need to bear this in mind when talking about the Christie loan. I agree that in an ideal world we wouldn't loan a player from Celtic but those are the financial limitations we operate in. You can object to Christie signing on loan from Celtic on a matter of principle, that's fine, but I fail to see how it was anything other than a net positive from a footballing perspective.