Match ratings [vs. Wimbledon (A)]- early edition

[ThaiPie]

Bass - 6
Bedeau - 6
Platt 5.5
Hinchey 5
Grant - 6
Whittaker - 4.5
Palmer - 5
Tsaroulla 6.5
Jatta -5.75
Abbott - 6.25

Wimbledon faster, fitter and stronger.

[NottsNotCounty]

Bass - 5
Johnson - 5
Platt - 5
Bedeau - 4.5
Taaroulla - 4.5
Palmer - 4
Abbott - 5.5
Whitaker - 4
Jatta - 4
Grant - 4
Hinchy - 4

Macari - 4.5
McDonald - 5
Jarvis - 4

Maynard - 0

[the_anticlough]

Bass - 6
Bedeau - 6
Platt 5.5
Hinchey 5
Grant - 6
Whittaker - 4.5
Palmer - 5
Tsaroulla 6.5
Jatta -5.75
Abbott - 6.25

Wimbledon faster, fitter and stronger.

Mine are very similar. You missed out Johnson who was a bit unlucky to be one of those taken off at HT, Whitaker and Palmer must have been looking on sheepishly in the changing room

Bass - 6
Johnson 6
Bedeau - 6 MoM
Platt - 5
Hinchy - 6
Grant - 6
Whittaker - 3
Palmer - 5
Tsaroulla - 5
Jatta - 4
Abbott - 6

Subs
McDonald 6
Macari 6
Jarvis 5
Edwards/Gordon - N/As

[BCnotts18]

I didn't watch the game but this quote from a neutral sums things up for me.

https://x.com/JoelFourBases/status/1...NionnRAwQ&s=19

Its Whitaker isn't even the only culprit. As much as Maynard deserves to be sacked, he's been handed so many spineless and entitled players who are obviously nowhere near the standard required.

[Devon Pie]

Looks like I'm slightly more generous, but share the overall assessment.

Bass 6 Would have saved second goal on most occasions
Bedeau 6 Not a lot worked for him but plenty of effort
Johnson 5 Still not on the pace
Platt 6 In the thick of it and picked up bruises
Hinchy 5 One decent tackle, little else to note
Whittaker 4 Needs to get stronger
Palmer 5 Wrong footed to allow shot for their second and missed a decent chance
Abbot 7 Always running, always available and shook off the rough treatment
Grant 6 No obvious negatives, but nothing exciting
Tsaroulla 5 Shackled most of the time, one off-target shot
Jatta 5 Harsh to criticise a striker for a defensive failure and up front hit the bar for third consecutive game

McDonald 6 Couple of errors in possession but showed some drive
Macari 6 Seemed to stifle danger in his channel and helped in attack
Jarvis 5 Needs to match strength to glimpses of skill
Gordon and Edwards not on long enough to judge

[ThaiPie]

The anticlough, yes mistakenly missed out Johnson. He was no worse than anyone else. We are missing McG, JJ and dare a I say it Crowley.

[irish_pie]

Looks like I'm slightly more generous, but share the overall assessment.

Bass 6 Would have saved second goal on most occasions
Bedeau 6 Not a lot worked for him but plenty of effort
Johnson 5 Still not on the pace
Platt 6 In the thick of it and picked up bruises
Hinchy 5 One decent tackle, little else to note
Whittaker 4 Needs to get stronger
Palmer 5 Wrong footed to allow shot for their second and missed a decent chance
Abbot 7 Always running, always available and shook off the rough treatment
Grant 6 No obvious negatives, but nothing exciting
Tsaroulla 5 Shackled most of the time, one off-target shot
Jatta 5 Harsh to criticise a striker for a defensive failure and up front hit the bar for third consecutive game

McDonald 6 Couple of errors in possession but showed some drive
Macari 6 Seemed to stifle danger in his channel and helped in attack
Jarvis 5 Needs to match strength to glimpses of skill
Gordon and Edwards not on long enough to judge

These look just about spot on... Jatta hitting the bar 3 games in a row is just depressing... our bench today was one of the worst i have seen... simply nothing on it to change a game... depressing stuff and can't see it changing at this stage... mid table here we slide 🛝

[MapperleyMagpie]

I'm sorry but some of these scores are way to generous. Apart from Abbott I can't give anyone above a 5 and some way below that .

[the_anticlough]

I'm sorry but some of these scores are way to generous. Apart from Abbott I can't give anyone above a 5 and some way below that .

When you go way under the mean it just becomes emotional and more about punishing players or venting your spleen.

If 6 is average, I just totted up my scores for the starting XI - 8pts under the mean, which seems about right for a 2-0 away defeat at a team above us in the table.

Many posters didn't give a single 7/10. That says a lot. After that, it only takes 3 or 4 players off it to lead to a defeat, and we certainly had those today

[flukieireland]

some players are difficult to rate as we changed formation at HT

Bass 6 not at fault for either goal, might have done better on the 2nd
Bedeau 5 think this might be his worst game of the season, slipped for their 1st and misplaced passes a plenty
Johnson 6 unlucky to be taken off.
Platt 5.5 outmuscled a few times
Hinchy 5.5 think there is a player in there, needs a run of games, which might not happen
Whittaker 4 game passed him by
Palmer 5.5 not strong enough in the tackle for their 1st.
Abbot 6.5 MoM but barely stood out
Grant 6 better in 1st half, not at the races in the 2nd despite a better overall team performance
Tsaroulla 5.5 didn't offer much
Jatta 5 outmuscled too many times and too many poor touches

McDonald 6.5 did well when he came in
Macari 6 nothing negative
Jarvis 6 did OK, but offered little