Very interesting all this. Like a lot of football issues it's just a matter of opinion. My opinion is at this level and a couple above, every person in the team has limitations and weaknesses otherwise we would be walking away with the league so, for what its worth, I think Adam Collin was better than what we have now, the 18 year old we had last season lacked experience and never justified his automatic selection over Fitzsimons and remember he has only found a loan position at a low level Scotish side this season. Slocombe left his previous club without signing for anyone else so not exactly in demand. It seems to me its just a matter of which weaknesses a particular manager is prepared to accept or if your personality fits