I was disappointed that Goodwin could not agree a one year deal with Andy. It should have been possible but Andy's agent may have been asking for unrealistic terms. In any event he is leaving at the end of the season. In my opinion he should have been playing instead of Bates in the last few weeks and if he is not given game time versus St Mirren as a farewell to the fans in the last home game of the season it will look to some as being vindictive. I trust Goodwin will see sense in this matter.