Much of this debate stems from consistency of performancee. This encompasses goals scored, assists, defensive duties, general play and decision making

So, when you consider all of this, how does Ibe fair against Dawkins, Wardy and Russell?

We can see that all have inconsistency to their games, hence why they are at Derby right now and not in the Prem.

IMO, I find Dawkins to be the most inconsistent of the 4, plus he cant string 10 games together without being injured (same accusation to Wardy). Also given ages, I am not sure how much more Dawks will improve, but at 18, Ibe has lots of time to mature which will surely mean he will get better

End of the day, Russell and Ward on form would be my current first choice as they tend to be most effective and consistent. Then I'd have Ibe. finally Dawks