I didn't go to the game but roly's assesment would match my prediction if I had made one assuming that I actually exist.

If I do not exist then more than likely you must exist but even that is not absolutely certain.

Gm is wrong to suggest that madness is the only explanation as there are more possibilities.

The fitness issue comes up a lot and I have questioned this only to be called a liar and an imposter,the relevance being unclear.

Why are our players unfit and why do we play unfit players ?