Freak result?

[FTD1983]

I maybe am being harsh, but imo we signed a good championship CH from QotS, he showed he couldn't cut it at the top level and now is back at his level and looking good again.

To me that screams that one of our most important players isn't cut out for the level we aspire to... imagine the rebuild we are going to need when we do go up?!

As of right now, Fyvie is, imo, the only one of our players worth a start in the top flight - that's a major worry.

[darrenshedtastic]

yeah ill agree with you there tbh durnan was a good cb with qots. maybe the step up was too big at the time not just in division but also in size of club. going from qots to united has different challenges. i do think if he had an experienced cb alongside him in the premier league he would have been good in top division. he needed a webster instead he had donaldson.

i do still think he would be decent if we got up. maybe not be the key player he is for us now but i do think he could cut it in top level if he got another crack. the experience will have improved him imo.