Lol Morgan is correct.

We lost 2-1 at Newark in the FA Cup on 29th November 1930

During my research one particular set of results stood out to me. They were against South Shields.

Of 4 games played (against the original team) the results were:

3rd November 1928 home Drew 1-1
16th March 1929 away LOST 10-1
28th September 1929 home LOST 1-0
1st February 1930 away LOST 5-0

This was around the time of the stock exchange crash. It seems some of our players had their minds on other things. Lol

We did gain a little revenge against the newly formed team in 1972 when we beat the newly formed South Shields in an FA Cup game at Millmoor on 18th November 1972.