Signings this season ratings

[CHIPBUTTYBLADE]

Baldock can defend i have photographic evidence that dissproves this theory,here is a photo of Baldock being outjumped by Stefan Scougall for a header which went in the net for a Blades goal............outjumped by Scougall

[shorehamoldboy]

yeah i agree george has done well with us if kieron stays to fight for his place its our best position for cover with those 2 battling for the rwb spot ive also not lost hope on enda he had a great first half of the season but just faltered like a few others in the second half of season dont forget the lad came from league 2 i think hes come in for a lot of unwarrented critisism

[bulmer1889]

500 post picture thread alert ..
Just steeling myself for all the pics showing why freeman and stevens can't defend, none of the midfield are as good as coutts and non of the strikers can score from 2 yards

[CHIPBUTTYBLADE]

Here is photographic evidence of why Stevens can't defend,the look on his face says it all,its like that old fella in the advert on the big dipper ride........."what sort of cheese was that".

[CHIPBUTTYBLADE]

Remember this in the last game of last season.

[gallonofmagnet]

I think Enda is better than a 6,Lundy also,both a 7 for me.Enda aint a league 2 player anymore he's a championship player.Ya can't rate 4 of em cos they've hardly played but ya gi a ratin to Leonard who's hardly played.I think Stearman improved dramatically after a sluggish start as a BLADE.UTCB

Leonard has played 12 games with a few starts in there.. the other 3 hardly seen

[shorehamoldboy]

could always play 4 4 2 i suppose with kieron on right side of midfield and enda on left

[Longshortandtall]

Blackman 7 - better than anything currently on the books. Still learning get him back next year.
Baldock 7.5 - his pace is his biggest advantage his defensive duties his weakest. Needs to improve crossing.
Stevens 6.5 - looked the part early on in the season but overplayed and made too many defensive mistakes late on.
Stearman 7 - improved as the season went on organises the back well but physically weak against robust forwards.
CCV 6 - started well but mistake in Fulham game shattered confidence, good pace and strength weak in the air.
Leonard 5.5 - Good first game at Norwich and cameo against QPR. Shocker against Hull. Good at RCB will improve next season.
Evans L 6.5 - Started off on fire but mistake ridden end to the season, hooked twice by boss in games. Will improve good shot on him
Lundstram 6 - needs to lose some timber. Good passer of the ball but lacks mobility and switches off too much. Not helped by being played with Evans it doesn't work. Jury still out.
Donaldson 5 - for £50k a bargain. Started well against Sunderland but finished with woeful performance against Brum. Didn't work when played with Clarke. Thanks for efforts big man but don't expect to see next year.
Evans C 4 - he tried hard but isn't fit and you wonder if he'll ever be. 1 more season probably but needs to find the pace he has lost.
James Wilson 1 - shocking signing. Injury prone and poor attitude. You could tell from his first interview he thought he was better than us. For a rumoured £15k a week someone needs to be held to account for this serious error of judgement.

Holmes hope to see more of him next season along with Thomas who has had a good season at the Shrews and has pace. Heneghan is a mystery as to why he's not featured more. He has most of the attributes missing from our defence 6 foot 5 and good in the air.

For Homes and Leonard to get more game time I'd like to see us try 4-3-2-1 with Leonard as defensive midfielder and Holmes one of a pacy three in front of a deeper two in midfield.

[herbert]

Blackman - 8
Stearman - 7
Carter-Vickers - 6
Heneghan - 3
Baldock - 9
Stevens - 7
Evans - 7
Lundstram - 7
Leonard - 5
Holmes - 3
Donaldson - 7
C.Evans - 2
Wilson - 1 - absolute f**cking shocker. Ridiculous decision. Never seemed a convincing one. No one's blameless here.


Wilder can justifiably moan about budget but what was he playing at in January? Why spend on Holmes and Leonard only to waste them?

[bulmer1889]

Holmes and Leonard signings are a mystery to everyone I think especially as he chased them for so long it's not as if they were last minute panic buys