Quote Originally Posted by its_a_goal View Post
I’m confused. Surely we’ve had the same 5 “defensive”players in all the games and the same 5 attacking players (if you ‘re classing Ferguson as an attacking player.

It’s also arguable that you could also put Shinnie in the attacking group as he spends a lot of time in the attacking part of the field (especially against “lesser” sides.
Absolutely.

Campbell seems to sit deeper. So far anyway.
Seem to recall him scoring a very long range effort for the reserves against Celtic.

You could also say by that definition that Ball is not a defender, he’s a midfielder.

I think it’s lazy to say Shinnie is a defender.
He’s played probably 99% of our games in midfield and is often our furthest forward player as he runs beyond the striker.