Islay. It isn't all about economics for those who think independence is essential. There are cultural and moral issues which are very important to some supporters. I think that the economic argument is more important but even the numbers that I think are relevant are hotly disputed by independence supporters. Telling people what to think is a mistake IMO. Asking for their reasons for thinking we will be better off financially as an independent country might help us to understand why they have the views that they do.