Irresponsible Dundee University students

[Taintedice]

The point has been made time and time again that Scotland would be different. I think trying to compare the SNP performance which is poor IMO with the performance of the Conservative party in Westminster which IMO is also poor is just reinforcing the need for change through the ballot box. The expression two wrongs don't make a right seems to me to be a convincing case for change rather than a
justification for the behaviour of the SNP in Holyrood or the Conservatives in Westminster.

Are you just going to ignore how the Scottish government is comprised of a civil service which is a branch of the UK setup and takes its direction from Whitehall. Do you think Leslie Evans would have been any more cooperative if there was currently a labour govt? If David Davis was right about anything, it is the lack of an independent Scottish civil service. Labour wanted to keep control of Holyrood from Westminster, though.

[BCram]

Are you just going to ignore how the Scottish government is comprised of a civil service which is a branch of the UK setup and takes its direction from Whitehall. Do you think Leslie Evans would have been any more cooperative if there was currently a labour govt? If David Davis was right about anything, it is the lack of an independent Scottish civil service. Labour wanted to keep control of Holyrood from Westminster, though.

https://theferret.scot/fact-check-sa...s-westminster/
I am not sure if this answers your point. It seems to me that the Scottish Civil servants are responsible to the Scottish government while being part of the UK system.