Transfer Rumour Thread 21/22

[Chick A Saw]

You just feel guilty because you know you laughed at it

Mair a sigh of pity than a laugh!

[ARAbCHNID]

Alan Preston is a fanny though

Yes, he can be a fanny, an unabashed Jambo fanny at that, but nevertheless he did wax lyrical about Tam's Tots.
Or is it Courts' Kids?

[Chick A Saw]

This is where we're getting carried away a wee bit just a tad. Yes we need signings but Dorrans was slow and ponderous in the Championship never mind the Premiership and was completely owned by Butcher in the Derby at Dens. Why on earth should we be disappointed about missing out on him?????????

I see the post from Jedi differently in that Dunfermline are making yet another good signing for their level to try to obtain their promotion objective while we have made 2 signings to stay where we are at best. I read nothing about missing out on Dorrans whatsoever!

[TerryTheTerror]

I see the post from Jedi differently in that Dunfermline are making yet another good signing for their level to try to obtain their promotion objective while we have made 2 signings to stay where we are at best. I read nothing about missing out on Dorrans whatsoever!

Just goes to show, it doesn't actually matter what you write. 😂

[stokearab]

I see the post from Jedi differently in that Dunfermline are making yet another good signing for their level to try to obtain their promotion objective while we have made 2 signings to stay where we are at best. I read nothing about missing out on Dorrans whatsoever!

It's the way I read it as well. Ambition.

Tams tots if that is indeed our secret master plan is a colossal risk bordering on negligence and one which astute owners would not make unless they were getting bad advice.

Step back for a minute everyone and ask yourself whether TA gets a chunk of commission for each Academy player sold.
Maybe all players sold.

The reason for retaining a lot of senior players who should be away is that he wants them, needs them, to balance the amount of youth that's about to play Premiership football week in week out. Risky risky strategy.

On the plus side, if there is one, it's a great chance for Chalmers Hoti and Mochrie to shine.

[TerryTheTerror]

Step back for a minute everyone and ask yourself whether TA gets a chunk of commission for each Academy player sold.
Maybe all players sold.

Possible but if think it highly unlikely such a detail will surface given our recent history.

I don't think it's inherently a bad thing to incentive based on this per se as long as enough senior players are also around. This is what seems to be happening at the moment I'd say.

[Jedi u-Knighted]

My previous post may have been badly written but Chick and Stoke read it the way it was intended.! I'm in no way suggesting we should've signed Dorrans but showing a bit more ambition to improve would be a start..

[shedka]

This is where we're getting carried away a wee bit just a tad. Yes we need signings but Dorrans was slow and ponderous in the Championship never mind the Premiership and was completely owned by Butcher in the Derby at Dens. Why on earth should we be disappointed about missing out on him?????????

Correct, he was utter crap for most part at dens by all accounts, he has signed for his level now, he is passed his best, decent ability but not what a prem side needs..Butcher dominated the first two derbys, the one at dens especially against Dorrans, McGowan and Byrne

Yes I know he scored in the third derby, a good finish although afforded so much time to pick his spot and tbf we were pretty poor that night and way below the level we had showed prior

[Jedi u-Knighted]

Correct, he was utter crap for most part at dens by all accounts, he has signed for his level now, he is passed his best, decent ability but not what a prem side needs..Butcher dominated the first two derbys, the one at dens especially against Dorrans, McGowan and Byrne

Yes I know he scored in the third derby, a good finish although afforded so much time to pick his spot and tbf we were pretty poor that night and way below the level we had showed prior

I give up.!!!🙄

[shedka]

It's ok, we know you didn't mean we should sign him just giving my opinion on him on the back off james post...Good to think about those dominant derbies, Hope that is OK with you?

I wonder when the window shuts if we will have made any signings, I think yes