Livingstone, don't know, unproven, may be worth try but possibly another Crawley, Westley, Bracey, Northeast, Lawrence and others who have briefly shone and made a case at "A" level, but not kicked on. Willey gets action from the new ball, but then nothing special for the next 70 overs. Don't think he is quite there at test level, bowls too many 4 balls.

The return of Ali plus Woakes, Stokes and Archer will resolve the bowling / all rounder issues, and allow us to move on from Broad-Anderson post Ashes tour: but the batting I fear is in desperate condition. perhaps its time to convert a few South Africans