Quote Originally Posted by freemuzzy View Post
These are definitely a fairer reflection in my view than some of the 2/10s etc being banded about. Get that there’ll always be different opinions but it feels like in some cases the ratings may as well be written before the game due to the preconceived opinions about certain players (Slocombe, O’Brien, Mitchell and - weirdly - Baldwin).
We all have our favourite players, but I always try really hard to base my match ratings entirely on what I see at the match. No matter how good or bad they've been before, every player starts with a clean slate.

As conclusive proof of this, I once made David Vaughan my MOM!