Dyche to Everton

[army88]

Thought I'd come on here and check the rumours but there's no thread so I've started one..
https://www.goodisonnews.com/2023/01...e-on-thursday/

I also heard another club was considering him but haven't found out which one yet.

Funnily enough Kriti I’ve just had the conversation with a very staunch Everton fan and they do not want Dyche ( the fans that is ) under any circumstances.

Personally I think he’d do a good job for them and told him that but he’s not having any of it.

Still think he’d keep them up if they get him in imminently.

Southampton for the other one ?

[Untinted Glasses]

Funnily enough Kriti I’ve just had the conversation with a very staunch Everton fan and they do not want Dyche ( the fans that is ) under any circumstances.

Personally I think he’d do a good job for them and told him that but he’s not having any of it.

Still think he’d keep them up if they get him in imminently.

Southampton for the other one ?

IMO it depends what a good job is defined as! Is it league position? Then he would do a great job like you suggest Army. If its having an exciting team to watch and enjoying football he would do an absolute stinker of a job.

It is easy to say, with a different brand of players he can change his style, do not pigeon hole him to Burnley etc.
However the more I think about it the more I know he can't. He has a negative mindset just like Southgate and it will not change. Again just my opinion.

[army88]

IMO it depends what a good job is defined as! Is it league position? Then he would do a great job like you suggest Army. If its having an exciting team to watch and enjoying football he would do an absolute stinker of a job.

It is easy to say, with a different brand of players he can change his style, do not pigeon hole him to Burnley etc.
However the more I think about it the more I know he can't. He has a negative mindset just like Southgate and it will not change. Again just my opinion.

I think your right UG of all people on here really I’m the one that moaned a bucketful at dross I was served up under Dyche s tenure - reality is if they went down it could be catastrophic for them and I think he may get a run like he did here where he could make them established and reasonably successful ( people forget when you are in Europe or potentially wining things about negative tactics).

At this moment I think they need a Dyche to sort it out before they slip ever closer to the bottom 3
And the drop.

[Untinted Glasses]

I think your right UG of all people on here really I’m the one that moaned a bucketful at dross I was served up under Dyche s tenure - reality is if they went down it could be catastrophic for them and I think he may get a run like he did here where he could make them established and reasonably successful ( people forget when you are in Europe or potentially wining things about negative tactics).

At this moment I think they need a Dyche to sort it out before they slip ever closer to the bottom 3
And the drop.

He would definitely do a job in that sense, in fact I'm convinced in the future he is going to get the nickname Sean Allerdyche

[sinkov]

IMO it depends what a good job is defined as! Is it league position? Then he would do a great job like you suggest Army. If its having an exciting team to watch and enjoying football he would do an absolute stinker of a job.

It is easy to say, with a different brand of players he can change his style, do not pigeon hole him to Burnley etc.
However the more I think about it the more I know he can't. He has a negative mindset just like Southgate and it will not change. Again just my opinion.

Please refer back to the 2015/16 season, that will prove that most of what you say about Dyche is simply wrong. Please bear in mind that it's not me saying you are wrong, look at the facts, we were top of the league playing good attractive football, top scorers in the league, the facts say you are wrong.

[The Bedlington Terrier]

Please refer back to the 2015/16 season, that will prove that most of what you say about Dyche is simply wrong. Please bear in mind that it's not me saying you are wrong, look at the facts, we were top of the league playing good attractive football, top scorers in the league, the facts say you are wrong.

By coincidence I was Everton when we won 1-0 and Jeff Hendrick smacked the winner in after a 24 pass move when no Everton player got anywhere near the ball.

I was also at Stamford Bridge when we were 3-0 up at half time against the EPL champions.

I'm not commenting on this topic anymore because if people had actually got off their arses and watched the Clarets play away from home under the auspices of Sean Dyche they would know we were anything other than one dimensional.

[sinkov]

By coincidence I was Everton when we won 1-0 and Jeff Hendrick smacked the winner in after a 24 pass move when no Everton player got anywhere near the ball.

I was also at Stamford Bridge when we were 3-0 up at half time against the EPL champions.

I'm not commenting on this topic anymore because if people had actually got off their arses and watched the Clarets play away from home under the auspices of Sean Dyche they would know we were anything other than one dimensional.

There were times in the PL when we played good football, Defour and Brady showing Spurs up at Wembley springs to mind, numerous other games as well, but as the money dried up so did the good football, I wouldn't argue with that. The last two Championship seasons under Dyche we were a joy to watch. Either some fans weren't watching us back then, or they have very short memories, no idea which.

[Untinted Glasses]

Please refer back to the 2015/16 season, that will prove that most of what you say about Dyche is simply wrong. Please bear in mind that it's not me saying you are wrong, look at the facts, we were top of the league playing good attractive football, top scorers in the league, the facts say you are wrong.

Yea your right I guess.

I know he did amazing when he was here, absolutely amazing. Maybe I am being harsh, I just think he needed a break from Burnley and vice versa. He became obsessed with negative football in the end. Like I say best for both parties I think.

I also don't really judge on stats, I just judge on how I feel. For the last couple of seasons I just felt depressed with the football .

Also players have spoken out about how they lost there love for the game too in the final couple of seasons.

[sinkov]

Yea your right I guess.

I know he did amazing when he was here, absolutely amazing. Maybe I am being harsh, I just think he needed a break from Burnley and vice versa. He became obsessed with negative football in the end. Like I say best for both parties I think.

I also don't really judge on stats, I just judge on how I feel. For the last couple of seasons I just felt depressed with the football .

Also players have spoken out about how they lost there love for the game too in the final couple of seasons.

If you want to talk about the last couple of seasons UG, no argument, it had run it's course and came to it's inevitable end. I feel a bit for Dyche because it's obvious now that Garlick was starving him of funds in order to finance the sale of the club. I don't see how he could have been expected to football the PL's elite off the pitch with the squad of aging journeymen that were all we could afford. He had to find another way to survive in the PL, and for a few seasons it worked, although I admit it was not pretty to watch.

I cannot agree though that he cannot play any other way, never mind the stats, I saw most of our games home and away in the last two Championships seasons and we were a joy to watch, there was never a defensive mind-set, even away from home, we just dominated games. I absolutey loved watching us those two seasons under Dyche, and I cannot forget the standard of the football we were playing.

[Untinted Glasses]

I cannot agree though that he cannot play any other way, never mind the stats, I saw most of our games home and away in the last two Championships seasons and we were a joy to watch, there was never a defensive mind-set, even away from home, we just dominated games. I absolutey loved watching us those two seasons under Dyche, and I cannot forget the standard of the football we were playing.

Yea fair enough. Perhaps he has and can again. Would he have the confidence to try it in the premier league? We were on a good run so easy to keep playing like that. A few defeats would he refer back to defensive mind set? I tend to think he would.

See us now, even when searching for goals in the last minutes, Reading game springs to mind, we keep playing the football we want to play win or lose. Not taking the easy option to revert back but fully believing in the style of play.

I just think a few defeats for a dyche team playing football he would revert back to defensive mindset. I dont think he would fully believe in the attacking style

This is all hypothetical of course. I hope you are right and in future we see a Dyche team ripping up the premier league with a great style of football.

I honestly do. I just can't see it, but who knows. Opinions are great and I do enjoy reading every ones.