Given the significance it was never in doubt I guess that he'd start Shinnie but he wouldn't be in my starting 11 never mind Hayes, can't fathom why he's starting in the slightest.

If he is going for 4 at the back then is it a sure fire sign that he's pressing the desperation button? Deviating from his persistent back 5 and just hoping beyond hope that it goes well for the team today.