Walsall Ratings

[SmiffyPie]

The issue for me with a 4 at the back is I don’t think we have the full backs to push on and create chances.
Brindley is reluctant to go forward and chicks for me hasn’t quite got that creative side, both would be solid enough but in todays game and our ethos of playing attack minded football I struggle to see them or Macari giving us that much creativity.

I think the most pressing issue until we resolve the weak midfield is to stop conceding. If 4 at the back stops that then at least we get is a point.

[i961pie]

The issue for me with a 4 at the back is I don’t think we have the full backs to push on and create chances.
Brindley is reluctant to go forward and chicks for me hasn’t quite got that creative side, both would be solid enough but in todays game and our ethos of playing attack minded football I struggle to see them or Macari giving us that much creativity.

With Brindley and Chicksen we wouldn’t get a pass over the half way line😜

[BigFatPie]

Would 4 at the back really make us more solid? As someone else said, we had 3 centre halves on Saturday and Nemane still ended up trying to mark the bloke who scored the first goal. The second was at least partly caused by Gosling not going with his man.

I’m more of the opinion that we have personnel issues rather than formation ones.

[SmiffyPie]

Would 4 at the back really make us more solid? As someone else said, we had 3 centre halves on Saturday and Nemane still ended up trying to mark the bloke who scored the first goal. The second was at least partly caused by Gosling not going with his man.

I’m more of the opinion that we have personnel issues rather than formation ones.

You are right but we (LW) have to do something.

[the_anticlough]

Would 4 at the back really make us more solid? As someone else said, we had 3 centre halves on Saturday and Nemane still ended up trying to mark the bloke who scored the first goal. The second was at least partly caused by Gosling not going with his man.

I’m more of the opinion that we have personnel issues rather than formation ones.

Exactly.
And as ever the 4 at the back talk is a waste of time really, LW isn't going to do it.

[nw6pie]

What would be everyone's best starting 11 with what we have available?

I'd go

Brooks

Brindley. macari. Baldwin .chicksen

Nemane Bostock Crowley jones

Mcgoldrick Langstafff

I could see Crowley doing a job for us in midfield, he's great on the ball, great energy and creative , with Bostock sitting deeper

Just an alternative to the 3-2-4-1

We need at least one person in midfield who can tackle and get about the opposition. Luke Young might be that player, if the Twitter rumours are correct.

Watching as a neutral, the most entertaining teams I’ve seen this season are - no surprises here - Spurs, Liverpool and Villa, and their midfielders run themselves into the ground making life hard for the opposition while also linking play with the forwards. Clearly, we’re three levels below that, but we need a lot more athleticism in the side to take the next step up - and that means no Connells, no Goslings, etc.

[maddogslater]

Anyone who doesn't include goldfinger in their side is out there minds.
He plays the number 10 for us , scores goals and is big robust and skillful.

[Lullapie]

All this talk, you can't get away from a good goalkeeper. They inspire confidence in their defence, which in turn, makes the defence play better.
Additionally I think we missed a trick not going for Jamie Grimes and tempting him away from Chesterfield in the close season. He's a born leader and gets the best out of those around him. He's a bit like Steve Blatherwick, a Nottinghamshire lad who was always 100% reliable. Notts lost Blatherwick to Forest, then he ended up at Chesterfield and he always came back to haunt Notts when we played Chesterfield.

Anyway bring in a quality goalkeeper and things will look better - that would be more cost effective than changing the whole back line.

[Elite_Pie]

Watching as a neutral, the most entertaining teams I’ve seen this season are - no surprises here - Spurs, Liverpool and Villa, and their midfielders run themselves into the ground making life hard for the opposition while also linking play with the forwards.

Matty Palmer anyone?

[Elite_Pie]

I think we missed a trick not going for Jamie Grimes and tempting him away from Chesterfield in the close season.

Noooooo. For all his faults, I much prefer Aiden Baldwin.