Quote Originally Posted by animallittle3 View Post
Nobody on here expects the club to keep it's better players , we accept that they move on and so I don't know why you felt the need to defend a position that didn't need defending .

As ever it's the replacements that are always the issue and it always goes the same way , we go backwards .

If you want to put the blame on the HC then ask yourself this , he gets a tune of MaCatee , Cole has scored more goals this season so far than he ever has , Kane is playing well , Connell too and Cadden is his usual 7/10 most games .

Half the team are either performing well or above expectations .

Here's where it goes down the pan a little .

O'Keefe , Russell , Cosgrove , Lopata , McCart , Watters , Cotter .

He clearly doesn't rate Cundy , McCarthy , Shepherd , Dallas and Shaw .

That's 12 players who aren't either performing consistently or even performing at all .

I think the evidence suggests with such a dog shyte hand dealt to him by the recruitment team to have us 6th isn't a bad effort at all from the HC .
Well that’s where our opinions differ.
I think all performances from players from last season has dipped this season - excluding Connell.

As for the new players - who knows - we have no previous seasons to gauge them by.
Clearly McAtee and Mael are good - but how good?

I wouldn’t like to commit to putting a score out of 10 against any of the new players - because if the previous players are not performing as they were (eg Kane, Phillips, Williams, Styles) then how do we judge the new players?
We can’t.
And that is the simple reason why ive not berated any of the new players.