Stay or go?

[OldMagpie60]

GO - It's quite obvious he's out of his depth, his obsession with going on about hotel stays in interviews show that he's just not ready to take that step up. We were doing that in non league as well, it astounds me that we even went for him in the first place, there was nothing about him that said he was capable of such a jump never mind having earned the opportunity with his track record.

It's clear the players are either confused by his constant change of tactics or just don't like him and aren't playing for him. I'd like to think we've already lined up a replacement but this year has really shaken my confidence in the decision making on the football side of the club

Yes it’s a worry. Common sense said that this was going to end in tears - we shipped 31 shots on goal last night so the defensive frailty is worse!
SM is a genuine, nice bloke but that gets you nowhere in the EFL - ad I said in other chats, JOB will galvanise the squad, provide some consistency and most of all he has respect.
Action is needed now in a last ditch attempt to keep the quality players we do have and protect the season ticket renewals. It’s a no brainer.
Only other option is Warnock for 10 games to inject some steel, urgency and humour!!!!

[slack_pie]

Yes it’s a worry. Common sense said that this was going to end in tears - we shipped 31 shots on goal last night so the defensive frailty is worse!
SM is a genuine, nice bloke but that gets you nowhere in the EFL - ad I said in other chats, JOB will galvanise the squad, provide some consistency and most of all he has respect.
Action is needed now in a last ditch attempt to keep the quality players we do have and protect the season ticket renewals. It’s a no brainer.
Only other option is Warnock for 10 games to inject some steel, urgency and humour!!!!

Maynard does seem like a nice bloke, and I'd love for it to work out for him. I genuinely feel sorry for him. But being nice isn't enough. I'd imagine Clough isn't particularly nice at times, but he gets the job done.

[KintoreMagpie]

Action is needed now in a last ditch attempt to keep the quality players we do have and protect the season ticket renewals. It’s a no brainer.
Only other option is Warnock for 10 games to inject some steel, urgency and humour!!!!

V pleased we stayed on after Aberdeen’s game on Saturday to give Neil a cheer as he walked slowly around the pitch. I expected him to go if they lost v Killie, not if they won. Bamboozled when we learnt he was stepping down as we drove away from the ground. Unfortunately, I suspect Neil hadn’t appreciated the size of the task at Aberdeen, nor the hostility of some sections of the media and fan base towards his appointment. Things only got worse with the Dons’ poor league performances and, after conceding 2 goals in injury time v St Mirren to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory, I think Warnock sitting alone in his hotel room after returning from that game must have decided what is the point.

I sincerely doubt the brothers would ever contemplate appointing Neil as interim manager as it doesn’t seem to suit their principles. However, after such a bleak experience in Aberdeen, I suspect that Neil would not take on such a role again.