interesting twist with Baldwin and Platt! Someone on here described AB as a Rolls Royce of a player, and when he's performing well he does seem to glide through the gears.

For me, whatever the defensive setup, defenders and goalies need to have a huge dollap of consistency. Leave the mercurial to strikers and midfielders. So I think it suits us to switch out a player with a season range of 2-8 rating, for a 6-7 one, but it will be interesting to see how they both do in comparison.